형제자매들

제목 없음

요.

maeip-0.jpg

 


49 교회 내에서 행해지는 다단계
[[제1160호]  2008년 12월  6일]

기도하는 집인 교회가 개인 수익을 위한 수단?


며칠 전 한 장로님과 집사님이 필자를 찾아와서는 돈을 많이 벌게 해주겠다고 한다. 그래서 어떻게 돈을 많이 벌 수 있느냐고 물으니 자신들이 하는 말만 믿고 따르면 된다고 한다. 그래서 그것이 무엇이냐고 반문하니 곧바로 다단계를 설명하면서 한 달에 천만 원씩 벌 수 있다고 현혹하는 것이다. 거기에 조금만 수고를 더하면 수입이 2천만 원까지 될 수 있다는 둥 하며 다단계 일을 같이 하자는 것이다. 그러면서 하는 말이, 이렇게 돈을 벌게 되면 교회 선교비로 한달에 천만원씩 내자는 얘기까지 하며 당장 재벌이나 된 것처럼 야단법석이다.

다단계 사업은 교회에까지 침투하여 성도들을 혼란에 빠뜨리는 등 심각한 문제를 야기하고 있다. 교회의 재정확보를 위해, 또는 허울 좋게도 선교비를 앞세워 교인들은 물론 교회를 책임지고 있는 목회자에게까지 다단계 사업을 홍보하고 물건을 판매하며 앞장서서 진두지휘를 한다. 심지어는 교회 내의 교구와 구역조직까지 다단계에 활용하고 있음에는 놀라움을 금할 길이 없다.

서울의 B교회 S목사가 다단계 업체의 사기행각에 연루되어 구속되는 엄청난 사건이 있었다. 내용인즉 컴퓨터 화면으로 원어민과 직접 대화할 수 있는 화상 시스템을 개발하였는데 이것을 다단계와 영어화상교육업체와 계약관계를 맺고 자신이 담임하고 있는 교회의 교인들과 목회자들을 끌어들여 피해를 주었다는 것이다.

S목사는 교인들과 목회자들에게 돈도 벌고 하나님의 사업에 헌금도 하고 선교 사업에 큰돈을 내어 활발하게 선교하자고 교인들을 끌어 들였다는 것이다. 영어화상교육에 투자하면 원금의 두 배 이상의 수익은 물론 자기 밑에 회원을 유치하는 실적에 따라 수당이 최고 몇백 만원의 배당금과 매출의 3%를 보장받게 된다고 현혹했다는 것이다.

이에 마음이 끌린 교인들은 담임목사가 설득하는 바람에 더욱 의심하지 않고 주변 동료들까지 끌어 들여 피해를 크게 입었다고 한다. 교회에서 다단계에 쓸려 들어간 목사가 30명이나 되며 사회의 일반인들 약 천명이 피해를 입었다고 하는데 그들 중 절반 가량이 교회 교인들이었다고 한다. 다단계가 교회에 침투하면서 어처구니없는 문제가 자주 발생하곤 하는데 K교회에서는 구역 예배가 시작되면 약 10여분 정도는 기도회를 갖고 난 뒤 자연스럽게 다단계 이야기로 분위기가 바뀐다고 한다.

어느 다단계회사가 좋다고 누군가의 말이 시작되면, 또 한쪽에서 아니다 S다단계회사가만 시 수익이 좋다느니, 또 어떤이는 돈을 많이 벌었다느니 누구는 빚을 지고 있다가 이 다단계를 하고는 부자가 되었다느니, 하면서 구역예배는 뒷전이고 그저 다단계 얘기로간 보내기도 한다는 것이다.

이러다 보니 교회가 A다단계를 하는 사람들과 B다단계를 하는 사람들, 이렇게 두 파, 또는 세 파로 편이 갈라지면서 하나님께 영광을 돌리는 교회가 아닌 다단계 회사로 변해가는 가슴 아픈 일도 일어나고 있다고 한다.

YMCA 시민중계실의 김경희 간사는 “교회는 이미 네트워크가 형성되어 있는 곳이기 때문에 다단계가 빨리 침투할 수 있는 여건을 갖추고 있다”며 “다단계가 들어간 교회는 교회의 순수성을 잃고 공동체가 파괴될 수밖에 없다”고 지적한다.

또한 안티 피라미트 사이트에서 지적한 사항을 보면 ‘다단계는 타인을 자신의 수익을 늘리는데 수단화하는 반 신앙적이고 반 인간적인 정신이며, 네트워크를 구성하여 잘 살아보자는 취지로 배후에 깔린 무의적인 물신주의’라고 지적하면서 수평관계가 아니라 철저하게 수직적인 상하구조로 작동하는 이윤 구조가 다단계에 깔려 있다고 한다. 또한 이는 하나님 나라의 신앙과 소망에 위배되는 일이라고 지적한다. 

처음에는 선교를 위해 그리고 학비를 마련하기 위해, 여러 가지의 이유로 소박한 꿈을 안고 다단계를 시작하지만 하나님의 말씀에 의해 신앙생활을 해야 하는 교회에서조차 어찌 이런 불미스러운 일들을 목회자나 장로 권사 집사들이 교회를 이용하여 돈을 벌어 보겠다고 하는지 참 하나님께 송구스러울 뿐이다.

모든 사람들이 말씀으로는 하나님의 은혜로 신앙생활을 잘 해야 한다고들 말한다.

마가복음 11장15절-17절 말씀에 ‘저희가 예루살렘에 들어 가니라 예수께서 성전에 들어 가사 성전 안에서 매매(賣買)하는 자들을 내어 쫓으시며 돈 바꾸는 자들의 상과 비둘기 파는 자들의 의자를 둘러엎으시며 아무나 기구를 가지고 성전 안으로 지나다님을 허락지 아니하시고 이에 가르쳐 이르시되 기록된바 “내 집은 만민의 기도하는 집이라 칭함을 받으리라고 하지 아니하였느냐 너희는 강도의 굴혈(掘穴)을 만들었도다” 하시매’ 라고 한탄하시며 성전 안에서 장사치들을 쫓아 내셨다.

그런데 하물며 이런 불미스러운 일들이 교회에서 일어나고 있다는데 하나님께 너무나 송구스럽기 짝이 없다. 모든 교회가 정직하고 바른 신앙의 자세로 오직 하나님께 영광돌리는 공동체로 돌아가 주기를 기원하는 바이다.   

 

심영식 장로

<한국기독교이단문제연구소 이사장, 한기총 이단사이비대책위원회 부위원장>






댓글 '1'

liuchunkai

2018.01.12 16:26:16

20180112lck

coach outlet store online clearances

canada goose coats

christian louboutin outlet

puma shoes

canada goose outlet

pandora charms

ugg boots clearance

air huarache

christian louboutin shoes

canada goose outlet

ugg outlet store

uggs outlet

kate spade outlet online

nfl jerseys

outlet christian louboutin

canada goose outlet online

nfl jerseys

pandora charms sale clearance

ugg outlet

cheap ray ban sunglasses

fitflops

prada sunglasses for women

nfl jersey wholesale

thomas sabo charms

michael kors outlet online

cheap jordans for sale

uggs outlet

true religion outlet

uggs outlet

ray-ban sunglasses

pandora charms

cheap ray ban sunglasses

michael kors outlet

canada goose outlet store

converse shoes sale

cheap oakley sunglasses

canada goose jackets

canada goose outlet online

polo ralph lauren

coach outlet online

supreme clothing

ugg outlet

polo outlets factory store

lacoste polo

ralph lauren polo shirts

uggs outletonline

soccer cleats

nike store uk

polo ralph lauren

ugg outlet stores

coach outlet canada

canada goose outlet store

nike outlet store

canada goose outlet store

coach outlet online

oakley sunglasses

christian louboutin shoes

herve leger outlet

nfl jerseys

cheap nhl jerseys

mont blanc outlet

coach outlet

ralph lauren outlet

coach outlet

ugg boots on sale

moncler outlet online

cheap basketball shoes

prada shoes

kate spade outlet online

swarovski outlet

true religion outlet

ugg boots clearance

longchamp handbags sale

canada goose jackets

tory burch outlet online

coach factory outlet

nike shoes on sale

coach outlet

nike roshe

toms sko

rayban sunglasses

christian louboutin shoes

canada goose jackets men

polo ralph lauren shirts

ralph lauren outlet

canada goose jackets

ralph lauren shirts

oakley sunglasses wholesale

longchamp pliage

michael kors outlet store

ray ban sunglasses outlet

michael kors wallets

nhl jerseys for sale

uggs outlet

herve leger dresses

coach outlet

longchamp pliage

nike shoes outlet

true religion outlet

michael kors

ugg outlet store

uggs outlet

uggs outlet

coach outlet

converse shoes sale

michael kors outlet store

denver broncos jerseys

moncler outlet

canada goose outlet store

polo ralph lauren

canada goose outlet store

true religion outlet

michael?kors?outlet?online

nike air max 90

max 90

cheap ugg boots

canada goose outlet

longchamp outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

ferragamo shoes sale

longchamp solde

true religion outlet

ugg outlet store

air max uk

ferragamo outlet

soccer jerseys

cheap ray ban sunglasses

michael kors outlet online

jordan shoes

ugg outlet

ugg boots on sale

ugg outlet online

coach outlet

coach outlet store

ferragamo outlet

ray ban sunglasses outlet

giuseppe zanotti shoes

true religion outlet store

christian louboutin shoes

tory burch outlet

longchamp bags

fitflops sale clearance

canada goose jackets sale

coach outlet online

ugg outlet

oakley sunglasses

uggs outlet

pandora jewelry outlet

canada goose outlet store

mulberry handbags

michael kors wallets for women

jordan shoes

michael kors outlet online

true religion jeans

ugg boots

canada goose uk

ugg boots

ralph lauren

michael kors outlet clearance

supra shoes sale

mac outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

polo outlet

michael kors outlet

longchamp handbags

polo ralph lauren shirts

canada goose outlet store

ysl outlet online

coach outlet store online

hermes birkin

true religion jeans

adidas store

uggs outlet

canada goose outlet

coach outlet

nfl jerseys

longchamp handbags

ralph lauren shirts

canada goose jackets

polo pas cher

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet

ray ban sunglasses

moncler outlet

christian louboutin shoes

ralph lauren outlet

uggs on sale

polo ralph lauren outlet

nike uk store

michael kors outlet online

basketball shoes

uggs outlet

pandora jewelry

cheap ray ban sunglasses

converse shoes

michael kors outlet clearance

uggs outlet

longchamp outlet

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

oakley sunglasses sale

ugg outlet

canada goose jackets

moncler jackets

ferragamo outlet

moncler jackets

uggs outlet online

coach outlet store online

kobe shoes

ralph lauren outlet

ugg outlet online

polo ralph lauren

ugg boots

vans outlet

ugg outlet

tory burch outlet

oakley sunglasses

nike sko

oakley sunglasses

broncos jerseys

cartier outlet

los angeles lakers jerseys

michael kors handbags

true religion outlet

air max shoes

michael kors outlet

canada goose outlet store

canada goose outlet

snapbacks wholesale

coach outlet

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet

christian louboutin outlet

michael kors

coach outlet store online

canada goose outlet online

denver broncos jersey

fred perry polo

nike shoes uk

toms sko

longchamp solde

polo ralph lauren

coach outlet

coach outlet store online

polo outlet

adidas outlet

oakley sunglasses sale

michael kors outlet

kobe bryant shoes

mulberry handbags

uggs outlet

coach canada

coach outlet online

nike air max 1

supreme clothing

adidas outlet

snapback hats

michael kors outlet clearance

coach factory outlet

yeezy boost 350

coach outlet

ray ban sunglasses

coach outlet

air max 90

ugg outlet逗号ugg outlet stores

coach outlet

nike sko

oakley sunglasses wholesale

cheap jerseys

canada goose outlet

pandora charms outlet

ralph lauren polo

coach outlet store online

oakley sunglasses

coach factory outlet

nike air max 2015

reebok outlet store

cheap ugg boots

cheap oakley sunglasses

fitflops

ray ban sunglasses

longchamp pas cher

ugg outlets

air force 1 shoes

polo ralph lauren

uggs outlet

michael kors outlet

cheap jordans

canada goose outlet

coach factory outlet

coach outlet

tory burch outlet online

canada goose outlet

michael kors outlet online

coach outlet online

cheap oakley sunglasses

football shirts

fitflops outlet

tory burch outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

canada goose jackets

cheap jordan shoes

ralph lauren polo

ferragamo shoes

ralph lauren

ralph lauren outlet

canada goose jackets

ugg outlet store

coach outlet store online

reebok shoes

kate spade outlet

polo ralph lauren

true religion jeans

cheap nba jerseys

ugg outlet online clearance

coach outlet online

coach outlet

canada goose jackets clearance

ray ban sunglasses outlet

hermes outlet store

jordan 4

canada goose outlet

ugg canada

ugg outlet

adidas shoes

hermes outlet

ugg outlet online

kate spade outlet

polo ralph lauren

nike air max 90

true religion canada

canada goose jackets

coach outlet online

pandora outlet

christian louboutin sale

mac makeup

swarovski uk

adidas wings

michael kors outlet

moncler jackets

new balance shoes

ugg outlet

ugg outlet

broncos jersey

kevin durant shoes

nike outlet online

ray ban sunglasses on sale

ray ban sunglasses

ferragamo outlet

polo outlet

canada goose outlet sale

canada goose jackets

Girls shoes

canada goose outlet store

chrome hearts outlet

uggs on sale

fitflops

kobe 9

cheap oakley sunglasses

oakley sunglasses wholesale

nike outlet

toms sko

oakley sunglasses

pandora outlet

coach factory outlet

michael kors outlet

canada goose jackets

coach outlet

football shirts

lacoste soldes

coach outlet

michael kors outlet

oakley sunglasses

cazal outlet

coach factory outlet

nfl jerseys

true religion jeans

michael kors outlet online

cheap oakley sunglasses

cheap jordans

adidas wings shoes

air max 90

pandora charms

ugg outlet

kate spade sale

true religion jeans

asics running shoe

uggs outlet

michael kors handbags

ugg outlet

new balance outlet

ugg outlet

cheap jordans

ray ban sunglasses outlet

michael kors handbags outlet

polo ralph lauren

salomon chaussures

coach outlet online

michael kors outlet

coach outlet

christian louboutin online

michael kors handbags

michael kors outlet

ugg boots clearance

oakley sunglasses

polo ralph lauren outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

canada goose outlet store

coach outlet store online

soccer jerseys wholesale

true religion jeans sale

ralph lauren polo

canada goose outlet online

coach outlet online

ray ban sunglasses outlet

nike outlet store

canada goose outlet

michael kors handbags

tory burch handbags

michael kors outlet online

true religion outlet store

true religion jeans

puma shoes

links of london

ugg outlet

true religion jeans

coach outlet

polo ralph lauren

canada goose coats

true religion outlet

coach outlet

coach outlet online

nba jerseys

ray ban sunglasses

true religion outlet

hogan scarpe

ugg black friday

mulberry bags

tory burch outlet

ray ban sunglasses

coach factory outlet

snapbacks wholesale

longchamp solde

coach outlet online

michael kors

coach outlet store online

ray bans

cheap nfl jerseys

uggs outlet

birkenstock outlet

christian louboutin shoes

mulberry handbags sale

polo outlet online store

canada goose outlet online

kate spade outlet

christian louboutin shoes

air max shoes

polo outlet stores

canada goose outlet store

coach outlet online

pandora outlet

fitflops sale clearance

polo ralph lauren

nike air huarache

ugg boots clearance

mlb jerseys

new balance outlet

michael kors outlet online

oakley sunglasses

christian louboutin

ray ban sunglasses outlet

foamposite shoes

michael kors uk

cheap jerseys wholesale

coach outlet store

christian louboutin outlet

ugg boots

polo outlet

marc jacobs sale

cheap mlb jerseys

michael kors outlet

fitflops sale clearance

christian louboutin shoes

canada goose black friday

jordan shoes

ugg outlet

polo ralph lauren

ugg outlet

tory burch outlet

uggs outlet

canada goose outlet

nike outlet online

polo ralph lauren shirts

bottega veneta outlet online

ugg boots clearance

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

pandora jewelry

cheap oakley sunglasses

cheap jordans

supreme clothing

vans shoes

nike store uk

ugg outlet

tory burch outlet online

true religion outlet uk

polo ralph lauren outlet

ugg boots clearance

longchamp pas cher

kate spade outlet online store

polo outlet

ray ban sunglasses

cheap ray bans

ray ban sunglasses outlet

burberry outlet

coach factory outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet

jordan shoes

canada goose outlet store

uggs outlet

timberland boots

jordan shoes

michael kors outlet clearance

oakley sunglasses

pandora outlet

ugg boots clearance

ugg boots for women

sport's shoes

coach outlet store online

ralph lauren shirts

michael kors outlet clearance

moncler jackets

links of london jewellery

cheap jordans

adidas nmd runner

ugg boots clearance

ugg boots

nba jerseys

uggs outlet

jordan shoes

longchamp solde

michael kors outlet

polo ralph lauren shirts

ferragamo shoes

ugg outlet

ralph lauren polo

true religion outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

michael kors outlet

ray ban sunglasses

canada goose outlet

ugg boots

barbour outlet store

nike outlet store

cheap michael kors handbags

kate spade sale

pandora charms

coach outlet online

fitflops sale clearance

louboutin shoes

prada bags

michael kors outlet online

oakley sunglasses

christian louboutin shoes

longchamp bags

hermes outlet

mbt shoes outlet

oakley sunglasses

moncler outlet

cheap jordans

ugg outlet

longchamp bags

canada goose outlet store

longchamp handbags

nike free 5

canada goose outlet online

ralph lauren polo shirts

pandora charms

pandora charms

nike shoes

christian louboutin outlet

hermes belt

ugg outlet

ugg outlet online clearance

ugg outlet

coach outlet

ugg outlet

oakley sunglasses

blackhawks jerseys

denver broncos jerseys

uggs clearance

christian louboutin outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

nike roshe run

longchamp pas cher

hermes belts

cheap oakley sunglasses

burberry outlet

mont blanc pens

canada goose jackets

michael kors handbags clearance

oakley sunglasses

ray ban sunglasses

coach outlet online

canada goose outlet

uggs outlet

mbt shoes

birkenstock shoes

supreme clothing

ugg boots on sale

coach outlet online

michael kors outlet

lacoste pas cher

nike shoes

kate spade outlet

true religion jeans

ralph lauren factory store

canada goose uk

coach factory outlet

coach canada

longchamp outlet online

lakers jerseys

ray ban sunglasses outlet

nike outlet

coach outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

canada goose outlet store

air max trainers

ralph lauren polo

nike shoes

ferragamo outlet

nike foamposite

ugg boots on sale

oakley sunglasses

pandora outlet

polo ralph lauren factory store

michael kors bags

zapatillas salomon

true religion jeans for men

cheap ugg boots

cheap oakley sunglasses

christian louboutin outlet

michael kors outlet

tods outlet

michael?kors?handbags

canada goose outlet store

polo ralph lauren

salomon outlet

christian louboutin outlet

moncler coats

uggs outlet

michael kors outlet online

mulberry outlet

ray ban sunglasses sale

christian louboutin shoes

coach factory outlet

oakley sunglasses

ugg outlet

prada shoes for men

ugg boots clearance

mulberry uk

canada goose jackets

coach factory outlet

canada goose jackets

kd shoes

ugg boots clearance

nba jerseys wholesale

michael kors outlet online

uggs outletonline

michael kors outlet

new balance shoes

pandora outlet

michael kors online

polo ralph lauren

mlb jerseys

swarovski uk

canada goose outlet

coach outlet store online

ray ban sunglasses

uggs on clearance

michael kors outlet

ray ban sunglasses

thomas sabo

ferragamo shoes

swarovski outlet

kate spade outlet online

michael kors outlet clearance

burberry canada

ugg outlet

mbt outlet

nfl jersey wholesale

cheap ray ban sunglasses

coach outlet online

prada sunglasses

ugg boots

michael kors outlet clearance

ugg boots on sale

canada goose uk

lacoste shirts

outlet christian louboutin

air max 90

ugg cyber monday

nhl jerseys

kobe bryants shoes

tory burch outlet

christian louboutin sale

canada goose jackets

mulberry bags

max 1

ugg boots

nike trainers

longchamp handbags

uggs outlet

barbour outlet

ray ban sunglasses

denver broncos jersey

canada goose outlet

uggs canada

ferragamo shoes

polo ralph lauren

hermes online

mulberry bags

ferragamo shoes

cheap snapbacks

canada goose jackets

nike roshe one

coach outlet

coach factory outlet

fitflops sale clearance

pandora charms sale clearance

christian louboutin uk

cheap oakley sunglasses

vans greece

nike air huarache

coach outlet store online

kate spade outlet store

coach outlet online

oakley sunglasses wholesale

ecco shoes

ugg boots on sale

ray ban sunglasses

mulberry handbags

coach outlet

fitflops shoes

nike nba jerseys

coach outlet online

ugg outlet

nike shoes outlet

cheap ugg boots

polo outlet

canada goose uk

oakley sunglasses

canada goose parka

coach factory outlet

canada goose jackets

michael kors outlet

polo ralph lauren

mlb jerseys wholesale

canada goose jackets

cheap nfl jerseys

coach outlet

michael kors uk

soccer shoes

cheap oakley sunglasses

oakley sunglasses

coach outlet online

nike trainers uk

coach outlet online

chicago blackhawks jerseys

ugg outlet

ralph lauren outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

tory burch outlet store

christian louboutin sale

ugg boots

michael kors handbags

canada goose coats

true religion jeans sale

ferragamo shoes

timberland sko

soccer jerseys

ecco outlet

air huarache

tory burch outlet online

pandora jewelry

fitflops

coach factory outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet

oakley sunglasses

birkenstock shoes

coach handbags

longchamp outlet online

canada goose outlet store

michael kors outlet online

jordan shoes

polo outlet online

michael kors outlet

canada goose outlet

moncler coats

cheap jordans free shipping

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet

cheap nhl jerseys

polo ralph lauren

coach outlet

ralph lauren

michael kors outlet online

michael kors uk

ugg boots

nike factory store

coach outlet online

salomon shoes

pandora outlet

cheap jordan shoes

nike roshe run

uggs outlet online

coach outlet clearance

kate spade outlet

lebron shoes

ralph lauren polo shirts

fred perry polo shirts

asics shoes

canada goose coats

ray ban sunglasses

canada goose jackets

coach outlet online

ed hardy outlet

ralph lauren pas cher

swarovski outlet

true religion jeans

michael kors outlet

ray-ban sunglasses

nike air sko

adidas shoes

cheap football shirts

kate spade sale

oakley sunglasses

ugg outlet

coach factory outlet

ray ban sunglasses

burberry outlet store

ralph lauren polo

true religion jeans

ray ban sunglasses

swarovski outlet store

fitflops

canada goose jackets for women

true religion jeans

dansko shoes

christian louboutin sale

canada goose outlet online

nhl jerseys wholesale

canada goose outlet

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet online

giuseppe zanotti outlet

cheap nfl jerseys

mulberry handbags

nike factory outlet

ugg boots

basketball sneakers

cheap oakley sunglasses

tory burch outlet store

mcm backpacks

coach outlet

ralph lauren uk

hermes birkin bag

ray ban sunglasses

coach outlet online

true religion jeans

ralph lauren outlet

ugg outlet

pandora charms

mulberry outlet

uggs outlet

christian louboutin

longchamp pas cher

michael kors outlet clearance

canada goose outlet store

fitflops uk

polo outlet

mont blanc pens

mulberry outlet逗号mulberry handbags outlet

coach factory outlet

nhl jerseys

swarovski outlet store

adidas sko

cheap ray ban sunglasses

michael kors outlet online

ugg outlet

canada goose outlet online

coach outlet online

cheap ray ban sunglasses

mulberry handbags

kate spade outlet online

cheap snapbacks

pandora jewelry

pandora outlet

michael kors online

ralph lauren outlet

nike outlet

christian louboutin shoes

uggs outlet

uggs outlet

true religion uk

canada goose outlet

christian louboutin outlet

jerseys wholesale

cheap soccer jerseys

michael kors handbags

nike blazer pas cher

uggs outlet

ugg boots

canada goose coats

michael kors outlet clearance

ugg boots on sale

true religion jeans

oakley sunglasses wholesale

oakley sunglasses

canada goose parka

longchamp outlet

cartier watches

chrome hearts

oakley sunglasses wholesale

coach outlet

michael kors outlet

true religion jeans

coach factory outlet

yeezy boost 350

christian louboutin outlet

cheap jordan shoes

canada goose outlet

nike shoes

pandora outlet

coach factory store

coach outlet online

nike sko danmark

christian louboutin

coach outlet

hermes outlet store

air jordan 4

canada goose outlet

coach outlet store

chrome hearts online store

kate spade outlet online store

canada goose outlet store

oakley sunglasses wholesale

swarovski outlet store

canada goose jackets outlet

longchamp outlet

mcm outlet

coach outlet online

michael kors outlet clearance

uggs outlet

tory burch outlet online

oakley sunglasses wholesale

cheap uggs

air max 90

michael kors bags

canada goose jackets sale

coach factory outlet

nike outlet

nike trainers

cheap ray ban sunglasses

fitflops sale clearance

mulberry bags

swarovski crystal

tory burch shoes

oakley sunglasses wholesale

polo outlet

ray ban sunglasses

canada goose coats

adidas nmd

polo outlet

true religion jeans

tory burch outlet

coach outlet store online

ralph lauren outlet

coach factory outlet

huaraches shopping

kate spade outlet online

birkenstock sandals

nike outlet

polo outlet

air max uk

cheap ray ban sunglasses

camisetas futbol baratas

kate spade outlet

polo shirts

ugg boots

polo ralph lauren

christian louboutin shoes

adidas outlet store

michael kors outlet

timberland outlet

valentino shoes

swarovski crystal

mulberry bags

canada goose cyber monday

lacoste outlet

converse shoes

uggs outlet

longchamp outlet store

nike sko

broncos jerseys

canada goose jackets

coach outlet

coach outlet online

canada goose outlet

nike shoes

prada shoes on sale

nfl jerseys

moncler outlet

michael kors factory outlet

cheap ugg boots

canada goose

coach outlet online

uggs outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

michael kors outlet

nfl jerseys wholesale

canada goose outlet store

mulberry sale

tory burch sandals

longchamp pliage

true religion outlet

cazal sunglasses

mulberry uk

michael kors outlet online

ugg boots clearance

michael kors outlet online

canada goose outlet store

oakley sunglasses wholesale

ralph lauren outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

michael kors outlet clearance

ugg boots

coach outlet

tory burch outlet stores

moncler outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

michael kors handbags

coach factory outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

nfl jerseys wholesale

michael kors outlet

nike air max 90

michael kors outlet online

ugg outlet online

prada outlet online

air max 1

polo outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

canada goose jackets

pandora charms

oakley sunglasses uk

canada goose outlet

canada goose outlet

cheap football shirts

michael kors handbags

coach factory outlet

ugg boots clearance

ralph lauren outlet

coach handbags on sale

true religion jeans

ugg boots clearance

michael kors uk

coach handbags

coach outlet online

ugg outlet online

puma outlet

cheap uggs

canada goose

burberry outlet

michael kors outlet

oakley sunglasses

uggs

coach outlet store online

rayban sunglasses

canada goose

lacoste polo shirts

futbol baratas

coach outlet

swarovski outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

ferragamo shoes

air max 2015

michael kors outlet online

ugg outlet

lebron james shoes

montblanc pens

coach outlet online

coach outlet store online

moncler outlet

christian louboutin outlet

cheap nba jerseys

canada goose outlet store

salomon sko

fitflops sale clearance

polo ralph lauren

chrome hearts outlet

canada goose outlet

ugg boots outlet

ugg boots

air jordan shoes

louboutin shoes

kate spade outlet online

pandora charms sale clearance

polo ralph lauren

air max 90

adidas nmd

mac cosmetics

cheap nfl jerseys

michael kors outlet clearance

canada goose jackets

uggs outlet

adidas uk

tory burch outlet

michael kors outlet online

canada goose outlet store

air max 90

adidas trainers

pandora charms

mulberry handbags

ugg boots

coach outlet

valentino outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet online

swarovski crystal

yeezy boost

uggs outlet

ed hardy clothing

canada goose

swarovski crystal

ralph lauren polo

coach outlet online

nike free running

nike trainers

ugg boots outlet

uggs outlet

ecco sale

reebok trainers

michael kors factory outlet

polo ralph lauren

vans sko

michael kors outlet

uggs outlet

michael kors outlet online

true religion uk

christian louboutin

oakley sunglasses

oakley sunglasses

michael kors

mont blanc pens

kicks nice

nike air force 1

reebok shoes

pandora charms

nfl jersey wholesale

true religion outlet store

ralph lauren outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

prada handbags

michael kors outlet online

mulberry handbags

christian louboutin shoes

michael kors handbags

canada goose outlet

canada goose outlet

ecco sale shoes

ray ban sunglasses

ray ban sunglasses

nike outlet store

michael kors outlet clearance

coach outlet store

canada goose

cleveland cavaliers jerseys

canada goose jackets

jordan shoes

cleveland cavaliers jersey

polo ralph lauren outlet

coach outlet

ysl outlet

moncler jackets

nfl jerseys

burberry outlet

puma outlet

michael kors uk

ferragamo outlet

coach factory outlet

coach handbags online outlet

bottega veneta outlet

uggs outlet

ugg outlet

polo ralph lauren

michael kors canada

oakley sunglasses wholesale

christian louboutin outlet

adidas nmd r1

cheap ray ban sunglasses

christian louboutin outlet

ugg outlet

pandora jewelry

nike factory shoes

canada goose coats

christian louboutin outlet

prada outlet

ralph lauren polo

polo ralph lauren

ugg boots clearance

ugg outlet

ugg boots

longchamp handbags

michael kors uk

michael kors outlet

jordan shoes

fitflops sale

ralph lauren polo

ray ban sunglasses outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

air max 90

coach outlet

christian louboutin sale

air max trainers

nike air max

michael kors outlet stores

salomon outlet

yeezy boost

polo ralph lauren

tory burch outlet online

supra shoes

fitflops shoes

michael kors outlet

fitflops uk

michael kors outlet clearance

nike store

coach outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

oakley sunglasses sale

burberry outlet sale

polo ralph lauren outlet online

longchamp handbags

canada goose outlet

coach factory outlet

cheap ray ban sunglasses

moncler coats

swarovski jewelry

canada goose outlet

coach handbags outlet

mont blanc pens

cheap jordan shoes

burberry outlet store

michael kors outlet online

coach outlet

michael kors outlet online

salomon sko

canada goose outlet

oakley sunglasses

michael kors outlet clearance

marc jacobs outlet

polo outlet

polo outlet factory store

ray ban sunglasses

kobe shoes

nike shoes

kobe 9 elite

true religion outlet

polo outlet

longchamp pliage

oakley sunglasses

cheap oakley sunglasses

coach outlet store online

canada goose outlet store

polo ralph lauren

canada goose jackets

polo ralph lauren

michael kors handbags outlet

pandora outlet

pandora outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

coach outlet

ugg outlet

nike blazer pas cher

michael kors outlet clearance

ugg boots outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

huaraches shoes

nike shoes

uggs outlet

michael kors outlet

scarpe hogan

michael kors outlet online

cheap jerseys

mont blanc pens

uggs outlet online

tods outlet online

michael kors outlet clearance

cheap ray ban sunglasses

coach outlet

cheap mlb jerseys

20180112lck
문서 첨부 제한 : 0Byte/ 2.00MB
파일 제한 크기 : 2.00MB (허용 확장자 : *.*)
List of Articles
번호 제목 조회 수
» 교회 내에서 행해지는 다단계 --- 한국장로신문 update [1] 249173
공지 교회는 장사하는 곳이 아니다. / 김정태(베뢰아대학원대학교 신약학 교수) update [5] 245240
공지 다단계 판매와 교회( 그리스도인의 직업으로 적합한가 외...) updatefile [1] 211371
18 [살며 사랑하며-이근미] 바쁜 지금 봉사합시다 update [2] 184315
17 [교회와 이단] 373 - 다단계에서 인간관계 형성의 문제점 update [3] 189122
16 어떤 기독교인이 바라본 다단계에 관한 글 (암웨이등...) update [7] 194115
15 월 1,000 만원의 허황된 꿈 / 흩어지는 교회 update [3] 219212
14 다음에서 퍼온 기독교인이 본 다단계 update [1] 220986
13 어떤 기독교인이 바라본 다단계 판매에 관한 글 --- 싸이월드 update [2] 225748
12 권사님이 다단계 판매조직 교회에 확장해 피해 커 국민일보 / 2012. 06. 28 update [1] 227457
11 또 다른 기독교인이 바라본 다단계에 관한 글 update [1] 228163
10 교회 안에서 다단계에 대해(암웨이) / 모교회홈피에서 update [3] 231598
9 교회가 다단계 판매업자들 '영업장'인가? update [3] 233315
8 성도여 흔들리지 맙시다 /베뢰아사람 / 한국신학 update [2] 234093
7 ‘다단계’가 교회 망친다 “재원확보·선교” 명목 급속히 확산 update [2] 237154
6 다단계에 신도 2만8000명 끌어들인 목사들 update [1] 239937
5 다단계 판매에 대한 기독교 윤리적 비판 update [2] 240371
4 교회내 다단계 판매 어떻게 보십니까? update [2] 240782
3 다단계 판매업 종사자에 대하여 지도자들이 취해야 할 입장 / 예수그리스도 후기성도교회 (몰몬교 개인사이트에서) update [2] 241411
2 다단계하는 하는 년들은 보아라 update [3] 244210
1 하느님과 돈, 그리고 다단계 판매 (CBS 방송 칼럼) update [2] 321423
X
Login

브라우저를 닫더라도 로그인이 계속 유지될 수 있습니다. 로그인 유지 기능을 사용할 경우 다음 접속부터는 로그인을 하실 필요가 없습니다. 단, 게임방, 학교 등 공공장소에서 이용 시 개인정보가 유출될 수 있으니 꼭 로그아웃을 해주세요.

X