형제자매들

제목 없음

요.

maeip-0.jpg

 



 기사수정
 교회는 장사하는 곳이 아니다흩어지는 교회
 
김정태(베뢰아대학원대학교 신약학 교수)

그리스도인은 성경적 방법으로 돈을 벌고 사업을 경영해야



십계명이 요즘에 나왔다면 ‘교회를 장사하는 곳으로 만들지 말라’는 것이 있을 것 같다. 예수님이 요즘에 활동하신다면 노끈으로 채찍을 만드사 교인을 끌어들이는 ‘다단계의 피라미드’ 사업자들을 다 내어쫓을 것 같다. 성전 안에서 소와 양과 비둘기 파는 자들에게 하신 “내 아버지의 집으로 장사하는 집을 만들지 말라”는 말씀을 “서로 사랑하라”는 새계명의 시행세칙으로 내렸을 것 같다.
다단계 판매에 연루되는 것을 경계하는 까닭은 거액을 벌게 한다는 허황된 꿈을 꾸게 하여 삶에 있어서 가장 중요한 ‘신앙’과 ‘사람’과 ‘돈’이라는 것을 모두 잃게 만들기 때문이다. 잃는 것은 자신에게 피해를 입히는 것으로 그치지 않고, 상대방에게도 회복하기 힘든 엄청난 피해를 가하고 있어, 신자들은 조심해야 한다.
왜 다단계가 그러한 피해를 주는가? 사람들에게 반드시 필요한 것을 공급하여 소모하게 하는 것이 아니라, 활용치 못할 물건 구입으로 그치는 경우가 허다하기 때문이다. 어느 일간지에 크게 보도되었듯이, 중국동포 장씨 부부는 “돈만 넣으면 한 달에 3백 만원 이상을 받는다”는 말에 넘어가, 1천 만원을 다단계사업에 투자했다. 그러나 그들은 회원을 피라미드식으로 계속 끌어들여야 약속한 고수익이 보장된다는 것을 나중에야 알게 되었다. 불법체류 신분이라 아는 사람도 별로 없는 그들은 투자한 돈 대신 받은 옥매트·정수기·건강식품·화장품 세트만 떠 앉게 되었다.
결국 장씨 부부는 셋방에서 쫓겨나, 공장과 작업장으로 따로 헤어져 머물 수밖에 없었으니, 그들에게 옥매트가 무슨 소용이 있겠는가? ‘먼지 구덩이’에서 힘들게 일하고 있는 그들에게 정수기와 건강식품과 화장품은 헛된 사치품에 지나지 않으며, 그들의 힘든 노동에 찬물을 끼얹는 것일 뿐이다. 그렇게 따로 살다가 혹시 가정이 파탄이 난다면 어쩔 것인가?
다단계가 신앙생활에도 피해를 끼치는 이유는, 교인을 바로 그 회원에 가입시켜 불필요한 물건을 값비싸게, 그것도 환불도 쉽지 않게 하고, 그 교인을 물질적으로나 정신적으로 어렵게 하기 때문이다. 어느 다단계 업체는 반품을 판매 회사로 못하게 하고, 제작 회사로 떠넘기기도 한다. 좋은 제품이고 좋은 회사라면 판매한 곳에서 반품도 수용해야 마땅하다.
요즘 많이 들어서는 대형유통업체 중 어느 곳을 가보더라도 그런 것은 상거래의 기본으로 통하고 있다. 따라서 그렇게 반품이 되지 않는 거래는 결국 자신을 회원으로 가입시킨 사람과의 의를 상하게 하여, 한 교회에서 마주치는 것을 어렵게 하여, 결국 한 사람은 교회를 떠나게 된다. 다단계 판매로 인한 금전거래가 파혼까지도 불러 일으키는데, 신앙에도 그런 피해를 입히지 않겠는가?
어떤 사람은 다단계가 생계를 위한 직업인데, 왜 교회에서 말리느냐고 반발한다. 물론 교회가 그들의 생활을 책임져 주지 않는 상태에서 그런 직업을 만류하는 것은 당연히 그런 반발을 가져온다. 그러나 생계를 위한 것이라고 해서 모두가 선하다고 할 수 없다는 점을 우선 인식해야 한다. 성경은 오히려 생계를 포기하는 것이 선이라고 말하는 경우도 있다. 신앙인은 직업을 택할 때에 하나님의 뜻을 분별하여야 하기 때문이다. 야고보서에서 경고하는 것은 하나님의 뜻에 따르지 않는 것은 악하다는 것이다.
“들으라 너희 중에 말하기를 오늘이나 내일이나 우리가 아무 도시에 가서 거기서 일 년을 유하며 장사하여 이(利)를 보리라 하는 자들아 … 너희가 도리어 말하기를 주의 뜻이면 우리가 살기도 하고 이것 저것을 하리라 할 것이거늘 이제 너희가 허탄한 자랑을 자랑하니 이러한 자랑은 다 악한 것이라”(4:13∼16)
내가 아는 어떤 사람도 다단계 판매 활동을 하였는데, 내가 ‘그’와 관련되어 몇 가지 일을 겪으면서 알게 된 것은 그 일에 한번 빠지면 그 일에 몰입한다는 것이다. ‘그’는 기존의 안정된 생계를 포기하고 그 일에만 전념했다. 더 좋은 일이라면 그만 두는 것이 나쁠 이유야 없으며, 또 자기 직업에 전념하는 것이 비난의 대상이 될 수는 없을 것이다. 그런데 그 일은 다른 것을 전혀 하지 못하게 하는 것 같았다. 연락할 일이 있어 ‘그’에게 전화를 걸면 무슨 교육을 받고 있었는데, 하루 이틀 받는 것이 아니었다. 물론 통화도 거의 되지 않았다.
그렇게 몰입하게 하는 것에 대한 피해자의 진술(www.antipyramid.org)을 보면, 그것은 일종의 세뇌교육이다. ‘성공했다는 사람들’의 발표는 참석한 사람에게 일확천금(一攫千金)의 허황된 꿈을 심어주어, 그 꿈에서 깨어나지 못하게 하는 것이었다. ‘그’가 또 다른 사람에게 자신의 판매활동을 자랑하는 것도 그런 유(類)의 것이었다. 심지어 ‘그’는 한 달에 일억 원을 번다는 말을 하며 다른 사람에게 가입을 유도하기도 했다고 한다. 좋은 대기업의 임원도 성실하게 이삼 십 년 동안 일을 해야 그 경력을 인정받아 연봉이 그 정도라는데, 그 일을 시작한지 일 년도 안 되어 그것의 열 배를 어떻게 버는지, 내게는 이해할 수 없는 일이다.
그렇게 일명 ‘고수익’을 올리는 방법은 물건을 파는 것보다 자기 밑에 또 다른 사람을 계속 끌어들이는 것이다. 어떤 면에서 그것은 다음 사람에 의해 버는 방식이지, 자신이 직접 노력하거나, 상품이 잘 활용이 되어 돈을 버는 것은 아니다.
그래서 불건전한 다단계 판매회사인지 확인하는 첫 번째 방법은 “회사로 데려가서는 싫다고 해도 교육을 들어 달라고 사정 아닌 사정을 하는 경우”이다. 또한 그 교육도 “제품에 대해서는 별 말이 없고, 주로 돈을 번다는 사업성만 강조하는 경우”이다. 그래서 “무조건 전업으로 사업을 해야 한다”고 강요할 뿐만 아니라, 졸졸 따라 다니며 감시가 아닌 감시를 하기도 한다.
어쨌든 우리 신자들은 성경적인 방법으로 돈을 벌고 사업을 경영해야 한다. 기독교에서 강조하는 상행위는 하나님의 뜻을 따라 사업을 해야 한다는 것이고, 둘째는 불로소득(不勞所得)이나 과도한 이윤추구를 탐해서는 안 된다는 것이다. 성경에서 왜 게으름을 비난하는가? 그것은 땀흘리지 않고 양식을 취하는 것은 도둑질과 같기 때문이다. 왜 고리대금업자를 저주하는가? 그것은 적정한 이득을 취하는 것이 아니라 타인의 땀과 수고를 착취하는 것이기 때문이다. 왜 창기(娼妓)의 헌금을 받지 않는가? 그것은 상대의 가정을 파괴한 대가로 하나님께 가식하는 것이기 때문이다.

김정태(베뢰아대학원대학교 신약학 교수)
jameskim27@orgio.net

 

     ▲     


Copyright ⓒ 2000 BAC
379-5, Shinkil 5-dong, Seoul, Korea
Telephone 02 833-3657ㅣFax 02 831-1676
E-mailㅣ bacⓐsungrak.or.kr


엮인글 '1'

http://bsbs.biz/christian/9786/5ff/trackback

2019.07.26 18:38

air max 90 sale in size 9 - air max 90 sale in size 9

nike lebron ambassador 9 orange sky bluenike air max black and shinynike zoom vomero orange whitemens supra tk society green gold


댓글 '55'

Catalina

2020.08.06 12:36:21

NFL Store Online Shopping NFL Gear Nike Outlet Store Louboutin Outlet Yeezys Boost 350 V2 MLB Shop Adidas NMD Pandora Charms Yeezy Shoes Ferragamo Outlet NFL Football Jerseys Air Max 2019 NBA Shop Nike Sneakers Nike Clearance Outlet Christian Louboutin Sale Pandora Bracelets Red Bottom Shoes Adidas Ultra Boost Puma Outlet Asics Shoes Nike Air Max 95 Essential Yeezy Boost Pandora Charms Red Bottom Shoes For Women Baseball Jerseys Adidas Superstar Nike Factory Nike Shoes Outlet Online Nike Shoes For Women Nike Sneakers Pandora Charm Vans Outlet MLB Baseball Jerseys Pandora Charm Bracelet Nike Running Shoes Louboutin Shoes Pandora Store Nike Outlet Store Mens Nike Shoes Jordans Sneakers Balenciaga Sneakers Fjallraven Kanken Nike Running Shoes For Women Adidas Store Nike Air Force Louboutin shoes Nike Factory Pandora Jewellery Pandora Earrings Asics Running Shoes Pandora Canada Pandora Black Friday Nike Factory Nike Cortez Nike Air Max 98 Gundam Adidas Sale Asics Running Shoes For Women Christian Louboutin Outlet Goyard Wallet Basketball Shoes Nike Red Bottoms Pandora Charms Sale Clearance Yeezy Nike Air Max 270 Womens Adidas UK Ferragamo Shoes Nike Outlet Balenciaga Sneakers KD Shoes Adidas Yeezy Nike Outlet Store Nike Shoes Nike Clearance Lebron 16 Shoes Pandora Jewelry NFL Store Pandora Rings Official Site NFL Shop Online Yeezys Nike Running Shoes For Men Nike Running Shoes Nike Outlet Store Online Shopping Pandora Jewelry Nike Clearance Store Yeezy Shoes NHL Store Nike Air Max 720 Kanken Backpack Nike Outlet Store Online Shopping Lebrons Shoes Valentino Shoes Jordans Shoes Ultra Boost Pandora Bracelet Jordan 11 Christian Louboutin Shoes Nike Sneakers Pandora Womens Basketball Shoes Louboutin Outlet Adidas Yeezy Sneakers NMD xr1 Asics Running Shoes Fila Shoes For Men Fila Sandals New Nike Shoes Nike Clearance Outlet New Shoes 2019 Adidas NMD R1 Adidas Yeezy Shoes Yeezy 500 Black Nike Shoes 2019 Pandora Charms Christian Louboutin Pandora Bracelets Nike Outlet Store Online Nike Store Online Nike Outlet Pandora New NFL Jerseys Asics Shoes Lebron James Sneakers Nike Shoes Nike Shoes Christian Louboutin Yeezy Boost 350 V2 Jordan Sneakers Stan Smith Adidas Red Bottom Heels Nike Basketball Shoes New Adidas Shoes Golden Goose Shoes Adidas Outlet Adidas Sneakers For Men Adidas UK Ferragamo Nike Air Max 720 Christian Louboutin Outlet Air Max 720 Nike Clearance Pandora Jewelry Outlet Air Force 1 Nike UK Pandora Outlet NMD R1 Air Jordan Retro NFL Shop Nike Free Rn Jordan Shoes Nike Air Max 97 Yeezy Sneakers Pandora Jewelry Store Nike Shoes Nike Sneakers For Women Nike Factory MLB Fan Shop NBA Jerseys Nike Shoes Pandora Rings Official Site Nike Sneakers MLB Store Official Site Nike Zoom Winflo 5 Official NFL Shop Air Max Adidas Jordans Retro NFL Jerseys Nike Lebron 16 Cheap NFL Jerseys Nike Outlet Online Pandora Necklace Adidas Yeezy Air Max 98 Nike Sneakers For Men Christian Louboutin Shoes Ultra Boost Adidas Nike Outlet Store Nike Outlet Adidas Ultra Boost Men Kyrie Shoes NFL Jersey

Walker

2020.08.08 19:56:22

Nike vapor max Men's Huarache shoes Green bay packers gear Custom Pandora charms Nike max 2019 Adidas NMD r2 Pandora jewelry locations 2019 Pandora disney Charms Pharrell williams NMD release date 2019 Pandora store near me Nike dunk high sb Nike plus Nike store Air Jordan xxxii Nike air zoom vomero Ua Yeezys Nike free rn flyknit Adidas NMD triple white Pandora heart ring Adidas NMD burgundy Authentic NBA jerseys Red Bottom loafers for men Fjallraven mini backpack Baby Nike sneakers Nike indoor shoes Nike downshifter 7 women's Nike flyknit womens Air Max 2009 Nike Air Max one New Adidas Boost 2019 Nike Air Huarache run ultra men's Nike rn 2019 Dodgers apparel Pandora friendship charm Packers fans Redskins jacket Purple Air Max Goyard tote price Nike Air Max 270 girls Nike 97 NMDS women Lebron 16 release date Purple Yeezy Niketalk Fila disruptor2 Asics gt 2000 4 Pandora letter charms Air Force one low Nike Air Force 1 womens black Air Max 1 parra Adidas Originals Stan Smith Cowboys merchandise Adidas 2019 White Nike shoes mens Adidas Yeezy 2019 Top selling NBA jerseys of all time NMD og 2019 Jordan 5 fire red Pandora 2019 spring Asics tiger shoes Adidas Yeezy sale Vikings hoodie Adidas Superstar slip on 2019 Adidas shoe size Adidas goodyear Adidas walking shoes Pandora flower Ring NMD city sock Off White Air Max Black and white Nike shoes Nike prestos Air Force low Nike mars yard Adidas Yeezy kids Nike Huarache sale Nike Air Max sequent 3 Penn state football jersey Yeezy shoes men Adidas NMD r2 Nimbus 20 2019 Yeezys Neiman marcus Christian Louboutin Youth Baseball jerseys Purple Nikes All white Air Max 97 Spiderman Jordan 1 Golden state Warriors jacket Custom ohio state jersey Adidas climacool 2019 Pandora bow ring Jordan release dates 2017 Goyard clutch Pandora stacking rings NMD Nike womens basketball shoes Nike manoa boots Nike sf af1 mid Nike Air Max 2019 junior Air Max pro Cheap NMDS Pandora promotions 2019 canada Lsu football jersey Lebron James sneakers Adidas Ultra Boost white mens Bo jackson Nike shoes Nike Air Max tn Nike nsw Nike be true 2018 Packers fans Adidas velvet Retired Pandora charms Adidas NMD r1 Dallas cowboys jackets for men Nike Air Jordan 11 retro Atlanta braves womens shirt Pandora sale Asics coupon Adidas crazy Lebron 3 shoes Adidas NMD bape Air Force one low white Nike air running shoes New NFL uniforms Washington nationals jersey Adidas Superstar 2019 releases Baseball jerseys Pandora hearts Best Lebron shoes Nike running shoes 2019 Nike flyknit 2019 women's Adidas wings Air Max 270 Pandora world Nike Kyrie boys Nike Air Vapormax boys Kanken Nike Air Jordan women Notre dame football uniforms Cheap NMD Adidas outlet Nike tekno Toddler Filas Nike flex 2019 rn mens Adidas limited edition Nike free tr 8 Vikings gear Boys black Nike Kobe bryant shoes Adidas Stan Smith Ua Yeezy Gosha rubchinskiy Adidas Mens white Air Force ones Yeezy slides Adidas indoor super Nike boys Custom fishing jerseys Adidas classic shoes Pandora jewelry rings Black Kanken Air Max shoes 2019 Michael jordan wizards jersey Louboutin purse Nike pride Asics kayano mens Nike Air Jordan iii Pandora animal kingdom Pandora valentine's collection 2019 Nike Air Max 2017 mens Lebron 15 Air Max 95 Adidas Yeezy Yeezy Boost 750 black Lebron James 16 shoes Pandora Rings Nike sb shoes Yeezys for kids White Yeezys Nike men's free rn 2019 running shoes Nike zoom structure 20 Nike odyssey react Nike Air Max 2019 blue Lebron James basketball shoes Upcoming Yeezy releases Pandora bangle bracelet Adidas Original 2019 Vapormax Homage to home Jordan 1 Travis scott Air Force 1 Adidas sneakers Pandora deals 2019 Adidas men Adidas NMD all white New Air Force 1 Nike Air Max 97 womens red Eagles gear NFL color rush jerseys Kyrie Irving 2 Pandora jewelry store Next Yeezy drop Nike Air Vapormax flyknit 2 Nike Huarache women Air Force 1 low white Adidas Ultra Boost Adidas ad Air Max tn Nike Air Huarache run ultra Nike comme des garcons Nike Jordan women Goyard mens belt Air Jordan xiii boys Nike Air Max 270 Kanye west Yeezy Pandora charm necklace Nike Huarache boys Nike academy Pandora jewelry store near me Adidas discount code Adidas munchen 2019 Harry potter Pandora charm Giants jersey Yeezy Boost 350 v2 oreo Custom ohio state jersey Nike 95 Custom uniforms Asics gt Fila disruptor ii women's Adidas shoe size Yeezy 350 v2 zebra Adidas neo NFL store Black Huaraches Packers shirt Ultra Boost Adidas 2019 Lebron 16 shoes Fila disruptor 2 black Nike element NMDS shoes New Nike running shoes 2019 Nike retro shoes Air Max tn Yeezy Boost black Eagles apparel Pittsburgh penguins hoodie Nike turf shoes Christian Louboutin shoes sale James harden Adidas Nike lunarepic Louboutin heels Adidas zx flux Nike and jordan shoes Nike Air Max 2019 Nike 97 mens Nike zoom men Gsh on bears jersey Jordan 3 black Nikebetterworld Boys Nike shoes clearance Wheat Air Force ones Adidas munchen 2019 Mariners team store Nike free x metcon Navy blue Air Max 95 Kobe shoes 2017 Air Max 2019 usa Jared Pandora bracelet Nike kobe ad Chicago bears women's shirts Air Max torch 4 Asics gel quantum 360 womens Slides shoes Nike High top Air Force ones Christian Louboutin wedding shoes Nike air zoom spiridon Nike vapor Air Max Air Max 2019 beige Nike Air Force 1 low New york mets jersey Cowboys hoodie Adidas NMD 2019 Mens Pandora bracelet Custom lakers jersey Vapormax flyknit 2 Nike air zoom structure Yeezy 350 v2 triple white Yeezys size 6 Nike shoes on sale Adidas NMD white Air Max 97 yellow Personalized NFL jerseys Boys Nike shoes Air Max 95 grey Olive green Air Force 1 Pandora wedding charms Yeezy moonrock Nike Huarache yellow Nike free run 5.0 womens Adidas Superstar release date 2019 Astros shirts Yeezy Boost 350 kids Adidas Originals Ultra Boost men Louboutin iriza Pandora blue Nuggets city jersey Adidas shoes 2019 price Nike zoom vaporfly Nike supreme Black and white Nikes Air Force 270 Adidas mastermind Steelers gear Kobe shoes for sale Pandora charm Ultra Boost 4.0 Grey Nikes womens Red Bottom pumps Nike Off White Pandora Bracelet Canada Pandora Rings 2019 Lions jersey Nike korea Nike Air Max zero womens Fila disruptor 2 kids Khalil mack bears jersey Dodgers apparel Sf Air Force 1 Broncos store Adidas high tops kids Nike Air Jordan x men Adidas Pure Boost Nike Air Max 95 mens Adidas Yeezy 700 Nike Air Jordan v Jordan 14 last shot Mens Nike free rn commuter 2019 Blue Lebrons Patriots jersey Thunder jerseys New Nike basketball shoes 2019 New Nikes 2019 Cleveland browns team shop Nike multicolor shoes Adidas NMD womens pink Black Baseball jersey Nike Jordan 11 New Yeezy Boost Adidas NMD pharrell Fila white Adidas Yeezy sale Ultra Boost white Air Max 90 essential Seahawks gear Air Max 98 for sale Nike lunar force 1 duckboot black Nike air womens shoes Nike Air Max performance 2019 Kanye West gorgeous Adidas Boost NFL shirts NFL store Nike free rn flyknit 2019 women's black Nike zoom fly Nike hyperdunk 2017 low Redskins jersey Nike pegasus 34 womens Pandora Canada promotions Nike shoes for men on sale Nike Air Max 97 Asics gel cumulus womens Adidas Ultra Boost triple black Air Force red Pandora charms near me Huarache 2018 Adidas Boost 350 Off White Vapormax Nike presto extreme Nike comme des garcons Adidas terrex Nike coupon code Pandora deals 2019 Nike Air Max 270 black Adidas NMD sale NFL color rush jerseys Vapormax shoes Lsu Baseball jersey Red Bottom loafers Adidas zx flux black Nike slides men Adidas Ultra Boost uncaged 2019 Adidas speed trainer 3 Pandora Necklace Carolina panthers shirt Nike Kyrie men Adidas Ultra Boost mens Jordan shoes price Stella mccartney Adidas sneakers Nike free run flyknit womens Nike Lebron boys Gel lyte iii Pandora promotions 2019 canada White af1 Pandora disney 2019 Nike janoski Tom sachs Nike

Parker

2020.08.13 08:01:32

Cheap authentic NFL jerseys Authentic NFL jerseys China Cheap youth NFL jerseys NFL jerseys 2018 Chinese New Year Jordans Foamposite Chinese New Year Shop cheap jersey Air Force 1 foamposite Jordan 11 easter Nike black friday 2019 sale Cheap NFL apparel Colorado avalanche jersey cheap Airmax 2019 black Cleveland browns apparel Cheap NHL jerseys China Presto Off White Nike stock drop Cheap Adidas Jordan 11 shoes Womens Nike flex run 2019 Wholesale Jordan clothes Soccer uniforms wholesale Youth football jerseys wholesale Christian Louboutin shoes Jordan 8 red Authentic wholesale Nike shoes Toddler Jordans wholesale Wholesale jerseys authentic Cheap jerseys online Okc vs jazz Cheap Nike shoes from China wholesale Cheap dallas cowboys jerseys from China Cheap custom MLB jerseys Nike foamposite 2019 Nike sb dunk 2019 Adidas Chinese Toronto maple leafs roster Af1 Chinese New Year Cheap NFL apparel Lebron James Lakers shirt Jordan 12 Chinese New Year 2019 Michael Jordan mvp Mid top Air Force ones Cheap throwback basketball jerseys Cheap cardinals jersey Coyotes kaChina jersey Air Jordan concord 11 2019 Baseball jerseys Air Jordan 6 Chinese New Year Cheap authentic jerseys from China New Nike Air Force 1 New orleans saints shop Nike girls Raptors Chinese jersey Nike chicago Wholesale NBA jerseys Off White Nike Presto Release Yeezy 2019 Nike Vapormax 2019 black and gold Nike outlet mall Kachina jersey Vapormax Chinese New Year Retro 12 Chinese New Year Jordan top 3 Nike team Cheap football jerseys wholesale Adidas NMD white Chicago bears hoodies cheap Yeezy Boost 2019 release Air Jordan low Nike wholesale distributors Minnesota vikings hoodie Nike retro shoes Jordan bookbags cheap Cheap NBA jerseys Canada Rockies jersey cheap Clothes at wholesale price Nike zoom shift Gs warriors Womens patriots jersey Orange Off White Air Jordan sneakers 2019 Concord Jordans 2019 Wholesale NFL football jerseys Cheap custom hockey jerseys NFL apparel wholesale distributors Chinese New Year 2019 Jordans Randy moss patriots jersey Wholesale Nike clothing Warriors Chinese new year jersey 2018 Youth football uniforms wholesale Nike tanjun shoes All black Air Force 1 Jordan shadow Louboutin sneakers Jordan shoes for men on sale NMD xr1 black Cheap lebron lakers jersey Broncos gear Cheap sixers jerseys Nike outlet coupon Off White Air Max Cheap NFL jerseys wholesale NFL apparel wholesale distributors Cheap soccer jerseys wholesale Warriors Chinese new year jersey Womens Nike Free rn 2019 Lebron James sneakers 2019 Cheap Nike Air Max shoes wholesale Wholesale Nike shoes China Cheap cowboys jersey China wholesale jerseys Wholesale hockey jerseys Yeezy Boost 700 cheap Jordan drops Chinese New Year Retro 6 Jazz city jersey Nike zero drop shoes NFL shop steelers Nike rainbow shoes Nike Roshe one Miami Heat pink jersey Timberwolves city jersey Cheap dallas cowboys stuff Wholesale basketball uniforms Saints apparel Cheap NBA jerseys from China free shipping Nike stock drop today Air Max infuriate Nike outlet cyber monday Jersey frames cheap Chargers jersey cheap Toddler Jordans wholesale Air vapormax Wholesale jerseys Cheap Air Jordans Braves jersey Black Huaraches Dallas cowboys hoodie Jordan price Nike men's free rn flyknit 2019 Pandora bracelet Nike Free rn $20 jerseys from China Jordan Retro 9 bred Ice jerseys Cheap Adidas NMD Chinese Nike newborn Nike winflo 4 Trail blazers jersey 2019 Nike flex run MLB shop Supreme Baseball jersey Jordan flag Pandora outlet store Wholesale NHL jerseys Custom basketball uniforms Cheap college jerseys Air Jordan 12 gym red White NMDS Pandora Jewelry Miami marlins Wholesale NFL jerseys from China Cheap NBA jerseys from China Christian Louboutin mens loafers NBA shop Nike free run commuter 2019 Baseball tees wholesale Retro 5 Chinese New Year Toronto maple leafs captain Foamposite cough drop NMD triple white Cheap grade school Jordans Air monarch Red and white uptempo Nike Air Force Cheap NFL jerseys from China free shipping Jcpenney Nike shoes womens Nike shox mens clearance Nike zoom basketball shoes Cheap NFL jerseys China wholesale Are Yeezys made in vietnam or China Most expensive Nike shoes Pandora letter charms Nike wholesale suppliers Wholesale Nike shoes Air yeezy Jordan 1 bred toe Wholesale Nike clothing Maroon Nikes womens Jets jersey cheap Cleveland browns jersey Wholesale Nike backpacks Raptors Chinese jersey Wholesale Nike shoes China Wholesale MLB jerseys Cheap baseball jerseys Calgary flames game Addidas NMD Jordan 11 Chinese New Year Jordan 9 low Arizona cardinals White high top Air Force ones Patriots apparel Jordan b fly Cheap softball jerseys Cheap Jordans for sale Bruins winter classic jersey 2019 Nike outlet Adidas NMD sale Neon green Nike shoes Saints apparel cheap Nike Air Max 2019 jd Los angeles chargers Cheap dallas cowboys jerseys from China Kanye Yeezy Cheap arsenal jersey Jordans size 7 Nike react hyperdunk 2019 low Blank basketball jerseys wholesale Jordan travis scott Dallas cowboys sweater Steelers throwback jersey 2018 New york rangers Seahawks pro shop Yeezy Boost white Nike co Adidas Yeezy Boost NMD olive green Jordan Retro 12 cheap Human Race China exclusive Jordan lane price Kanye West new shoes Nike vapormax black Jordan 11 heiress Green bay packers clothes Air Jordan 5 gs light aqua New Adidas Ultra Boost 2019 Steelers merchandise cheap Pandora butterfly charm Cheap arsenal jersey Adidas shoes Adidas Yeezy Pandora Pandora Pandora Charms sale Nike grandstand 2 Jordan 5 Chinese New Year Air Force foamposite Real Yeezy Boost 350 Wholesale jerseys 2020 Golden state Warriors shorts Cheap seahawks jerseys Infant Nike Sam darnold jets jersey Rockets Chinese jersey Chinese jerseys $20 jerseys from China Majestic baseball jerseys wholesale Toddler Nike shoes clearance NFL apparel wholesale distributors Browns team shop Gsh on bears jersey Nike flight 89 Cheap baker mayfield jersey Custom phillies jersey Lakers clothing Dallas cowboys leather jacket Cheap hockey jerseys Canada Redskins gear Huarache shoes Arizona coyotes kachina Youth softball jerseys wholesale Dallas cowboys sweatshirt White roshes mens Red sox jersey cheap Coyotes kaChina jersey Bryce harper phillies jersey Chinese New Year Kyrie Top jersey wholesale Jordan 12 Retro Chinese New Year Adidas Yeezy Boost 2019 Wholesale nfl football jerseys Cheap authentic Yeezys v2 Wholesale jerseys 2020 Wholesale football jerseys Jordan 4 levis Nike Cortez womens white Cheap Jordan shoes online Custom NBA jersey maker Playstation Air Force 1 Cheap jerseys from China free shipping Cheap NBA jerseys from China Wholesale NFL jerseys from China New Nike Huarache Adidas NMD release january 2019 Black Red Bottoms Air Max zero Wholesale NBA jerseys Start Pandora Yeezy Boost 360 Kachina jersey Air Max ltd 3 Nike foamposite release dates 2018 Wholesale baseball t shirts Wholesale Nike sneakers NFL shop steelers 2019 Nike Air Max flyknit Vapormax plus 2019 Huarache tennis shoes Nike Air Force 1 07 lv8 Nike mens

Nicholas

2020.08.23 06:03:16

Red Bottom Shoes Cheap Nike Shoes Adidas NMD Adidas UK Adidas Ultra Boost Uncaged Nike Store Adidas Sale Nike Clearance Store Kyrie Irving Shoes NFL Shop Official Nike Air Force Nike UK Nike Sneakers For Men Louboutin Outlet Pandora Charms Sale Clearance Nike Factory Adidas NMD R1 Adidas Yeezy Puma Store Christian Louboutin Shoes Pandora Outlet Pandora Outlet Online Pandora Ring MLB Jerseys Vans Shoes Outlet Nike Shoes Adidas Shoes Adidas Trainers Nike Sneakers New Adidas 2019 Christian Louboutin Outlet Red Bottoms Louboutin Pandora Jewelry Nike Running Shoes For Men Nike Outlet Store Lebron James Shoes Christian Louboutin Outlet Ferragamo Shoes Nike Air Max Air Jordan 11 Red Bottoms Pandora Charms Sale Clearance Ultraboost Basketball Shoes Asics Running Shoes Nike Factory Store Nike Sneakers For Men Pandora Canada MLB Store Nike Outlet Store Online Shopping Yeezy Boost Nike Outlet Store Online Shopping New Nike Shoes Ultra Boost Adidas Pandora Jewelry Official Site NFL Jerseys Christian Louboutin Heels Pandora Jewelry Black Friday Golden Goose Sneakers Fila Shoes For Women Asics Running Shoes Air Max 98 Air Max 2019 Fjallraven Kanken Yeezy Boost Lebron 16 Pandora Bracelet Nike Outlet Adidas Yeezy Yeezy Boost 350 V2 Nike Air Max 95 Adidas Yeezy Nike Running Shoes Ferragamo Nike Shoes Balenciaga Sneakers MLB Fan Shop Nike Air Max 720 Christian Louboutin Shoes Red Bottom Heels Christian Louboutin Fjallraven Backpack Michael Jordan Shoes Jordans Sneakers Adidas Sneakers Nike Outlet Christian Louboutin Shoes Outlet Nike Clearance NFL Jerseys Pandora Rings Nike Outlet Adidas Stan Smith Nike Zoom Pandora Outlet Nike Shoes Air Jordan Retro MLB Shop Nike Sneakers Nike Outlet Store Nike Air Max 720 Men Nike Outlet Store Online Adidas NMD R1 NFL Shop Nike Factory Yeezy Pandora Bracelets Jordan Shoes Air Force 1 Low Nike Men's Running Shoes Goyard Bags Adidas Yeezys Adidas Sneakers Nike Shoes For Men Nike Air Max 270 NBA Shop Pandora Jewelry Official Site Valentino Sandals Pandora Jewellery Air Jordan Retro Adidas Stores NFL Pro Shop Pandora Bracelet Charms Christian Louboutin Nike Outlet Online Nike Lebron 16 Adidas Superstar Women New Nike Shoes NBA Jersey Nike Outlet Store Online Shopping Nike Factory Outlet Yeezys Nike Clearance Store Jordans Sneakers Fila Footwear Nike Cortez Men Louboutin Shoes NFL Store Nike Air Max 2019 Nike Basketball Shoes Kevin Durant Shoes Ferragamo Belts Pandora Rings Yeezy 500 Black Nike Free Run Nike Outlet Asics Running Shoes Red Bottom Shoes For Women Nike Running Shoes For Women Pandora Official Site NFL Jerseys Cheap NHL Store Asics Running Shoes Official NFL Jersey Pandora Pandora Necklace Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 V2 Balenciaga NFL Apparel NMD Yeezy New Nike Shoes Nike Sneakers For Women Nike Shoes NFL Jerseys Asics Nike Basketball Shoes Pandora Charms Outlet Nike Air Max 97 Air Max 98 Mens Nike Shoes NFL Store Online Shopping Pandora Jewelry Lebron James Sneakers Nike Clearance Nike Shoes Ultra Boost Adidas Nike Shoes Pandora Charm Bracelet Yeezy Nike Outlet Store Online Pandora Charms MLB Jerseys

Parker

2020.09.12 12:39:25

Rams shirt Michael Jordan autograph Off White Nike zoom fly Stephen curry Chinese new year jersey NBA store locations Cheap new orleans saints jerseys Jordan Chinese New Year 2018 Nike drop Custom Air Forces Chinese New Year Air Max 98 Lebron 14 Best cheap jersey site Seahawks gear cheap Retro 12 Chinese New Year 2019 Cheap Air Max 95 wholesale Off White red Nike Air Max 90 womens Eagles jersey Nike revolution 3 womens Soccer uniforms wholesale Cheap authentic MLB jerseys Cheap Adidas joggers mens Cardinals jersey Nike free shipping Galaxy 2019 Adidas Wholesale jerseys 2019 Chinese Nike shoes Cheap soccer jerseys Jordan Retro 6 Chinese New Year NFL jackets wholesale Christian Louboutin sneakers women Chinese jersey website Louboutin shoes How to get authentic Jordans wholesale Cheap baseball jerseys China Nike mayfly woven All black roshes Warriors Chinese heritage jersey Kids NFL jerseys Off White Nike drop NBA shop Steelers apparel Jordan jackets cheap Dallas cowboys jerseys Boston red sox jersey cheap Lebron 11 Jordan 3 hall of fame Chinese jerseys Yeezy original Next off white Nike drop Bears orange jersey Air Max mens 2019 Cheap dallas cowboys stuff Wholesale jerseys 2019 Air Max 90 Chinese New Year Chinese New Year Jordan 6 Jordan dna lx NFL apparel wholesale distributors Yeezy shoe releases 2019 Utah jazz uniforms Toronto maple leafs goalies Nike drop Jordan shoes China Off White las vegas Cheap lakers gear Nike zoom vaporfly 4 Cheap Red Bottom shoes under $100 Vikings jersey Cheap NBA jerseys from China Retro 13 wheat Nike shox nz womens Adidas Yeezy Houston rockets Chinese jersey meaning 2018 Jordan Air Max Nike sneaker boots mens Curry Chinese new year jersey Youth Baseball uniforms Jordan 18s Pelicans jersey Adidas NMD r1 pk Nike China jersey Rams gear cheap Yankees red sox Cheap NFL jerseys usa Toronto Raptors logo Y3 shoes Womens Air Force 1 Yeezy 350 zebra NFL pro shop Jordan Retro 6 Chinese New Year Nike lunar boots Adidas NMD Nike air zoom vomero Cheap black Jordans All black Nikes womens Cheap mets jerseys Nike Air Jordan vii Golden knights jersey cheap Black Huaraches mens Jordans coming out in may 2019 Buy Nike wholesale price Wholesale soccer jerseys New york giants shop Wholesale baseball jerseys NFL jerseys China Jordan Retro 5 red Nike sneakers for men running Jordans size 13 mens Nike react hyperdunk 2017 Nike air mag NMD Chinese Travis scott Air Force 1 Air Max 270 Steelers clothing Red and black Huaraches Jordan love Pandora unicorn charm Air Force 1 low white Cheap jersey website Jordan 33 Chinese New Year Nike dual fusion womens Nike wholesale China Blank football jerseys wholesale NFL shop jerseys Nike shox women Steelers game Nike Air Max ld zero Jordan release january 2018 Nike womens runners Nike wholesale distributors Mora Pandora Nike air zoom mariah flyknit racer Chinese New Year Jordans 2019 Cheap new orleans saints jerseys China Houston rockets Chinese jersey meaning 2018 NMD japan black Wholesale blank jerseys Nike mens What does gsh mean on the bears uniform Adidas soccer jerseys wholesale Padres jersey Pandora bracelet sale Pandora valentine's collection 2019 Nike upcoming releases Custom basketball jerseys Cheapest NFL team Lakers basketball shorts Nike outlet mall Nike Air Max 2019 white black Houston rockets Chinese jersey meaning 2018 Baseball tees wholesale Where to buy Jordans Pandora disney Nike off white drop Nike Huarache ultra Grey Air Max Wholesale jerseys authentic Vapormax Chinese New Year Chicago bulls hoodie cheap Blank youth football jerseys wholesale Adidas shoes NMD r1 Adidas NMD black and white Wholesale hockey jerseys Washington capitals stanley cup Cheap new orleans saints jerseys China Cheap cleveland browns jersey Chinese NBA jerseys Nike flyknit lunar Nike Air Max 2019 kids Nike outlet women Cheap NFL jerseys from China Soccer uniforms wholesale Nike Air Max 2019 price Nike outlet Cheap NFL jerseys from China Raiders jersey cheap Cheap jerseys from China Cheap soccer jerseys from China Air Max 90 Nike uptempo 2019 Reversible basketball uniforms wholesale NMD Chinese Aj4 Jordan 4 toro Cheap wholesale Jordans Cheap goalkeeper jerseys Jordan 6 rings cheap Nike Air Max 2019 black and blue Youth soccer uniforms wholesale Wholesale Air Max Pandora daisy ring Air Max 98 Chinese New Year Nike Jordan men Soccer team uniforms wholesale Jordan 13 blue and white MLB store Dallas cowboys youth jerseys cheap Nike Air Force 1 mid black Canucks store Nike black friday sale 2019 Wholesale hockey jerseys Space Jam cast Nike zero drop Spirit jersey wholesale Christian Louboutin bags Pandora nyc NMD 2019 Army football jersey New york yankees custom jersey Af1 high Cheap jersey websites legit New Jordan 8 Buy Air Max 2019 Nike outlet black friday Cheap jerseys from China review Nike epic react Notre dame football uniforms Cheap football jerseys wholesale Nike no lace shoes Youth baseball jerseys wholesale MLB jerseys China Kanye West Yeezys Wholesale Jordans China Jordan air force 1 Yeezy v1 Raiders clothing Air monarch Miami Heat jersey vice Wholesale jerseys 2018 San francisco 49ers jersey Cheap Adidas shoes Adidas NMD r1 white Travis scott Nike Official NFL jerseys cheap Army football uniforms 2018 Houston rockets Chinese Jordan 6 rings cheap China wholesale jerseys Cheap authentic jerseys from China San diego chargers Air Force 1 2019 Houston rockets Chinese jersey meaning 2018 Nike air bakin Plain jerseys wholesale Chinese Human Race Jordan drops 2018 Vikings gear Lakers store Stephen curry Chinese new year jersey Nike Air Max Chinese New Year Cheap authentic jerseys from China Cheap Adidas sweatpants Redskins apparel New orleans saints merchandise New Yeezy release 2019 Winnipeg jets reddit Travis scott Nike Air Force 1 Cheap jerseys wholesale online review Warriors jacket Cheap Adidas joggers Jordan Retro 1s Cheap stitched NFL jerseys Grey and orange Yeezys Basketball jersey New Jordan 11 2019 Best Nike running shoes for men Yankees jersey cheap New Kanye Huarache 2018 Authentic NFL jerseys China Blue jays de Toronto Wholesale Air Force ones Nike walking shoes for women Kids Air Max 270 Nike in China Yeezy made in China Cheap new orleans saints jerseys china Nike roshe flyknit Nike make your own shoes Packers fans Adidas NMD 2019 release Vegas golden knights jersey Womens patriots shirts cheap Cheap minnesota vikings apparel Black Nikes Nike factory store Pandora Jewelry Canada Authorized Nike wholesale suppliers Green bay packers hoodies cheap Cheap broncos gear Retro 5 Chinese New Year Retro 9 black and white Pittsburgh steelers gear cheap MLB shop dodgers Cheap NFL jerseys wholesale Off White Vapormax 2018 Uptempo 97 Pittsburgh steelers clothing cheap Nike Air Max shoes wholesale Mens Jordan basketball shoes Flyers jersey Warriors Chinese new year jersey 2018 Free run flyknit 2019 Wholesale jerseys USA Adidas NMD pink Nike sb janoski max Jordan 1 2019 releases Cheap NBA jerseys from China free shipping Nike 2019 Free Run Plain jerseys wholesale Youth Baseball jerseys Cheap NBA jerseys
문서 첨부 제한 : 0Byte/ 2.00MB
파일 제한 크기 : 2.00MB (허용 확장자 : *.*)
List of Articles
번호 제목 조회 수
공지 교회 내에서 행해지는 다단계 --- 한국장로신문 [19] [1] 183743
» 교회는 장사하는 곳이 아니다. / 김정태(베뢰아대학원대학교 신약학 교수) [55] [1] 217401
공지 다단계 판매와 교회( 그리스도인의 직업으로 적합한가 외...) file [6] 1056764
18 어떤 기독교인이 바라본 다단계에 관한 글 (암웨이등...) update [22] 186129
17 [교회와 이단] 373 - 다단계에서 인간관계 형성의 문제점 [25] 189696
16 교회가 다단계 판매업자들 '영업장'인가? [33] 194925
15 다단계에 신도 2만8000명 끌어들인 목사들 update [64] 200899
14 다단계하는 하는 년들은 보아라 [8] 203113
13 다단계 판매에 대한 기독교 윤리적 비판 update [25] 223902
12 다단계 판매업 종사자에 대하여 지도자들이 취해야 할 입장 / 예수그리스도 후기성도교회 (몰몬교 개인사이트에서) [6] 224250
11 다음에서 퍼온 기독교인이 본 다단계 update [44] 230021
10 월 1,000 만원의 허황된 꿈 / 흩어지는 교회 update [22] 236294
9 교회 안에서 다단계에 대해(암웨이) / 모교회홈피에서 [18] 245951
8 하느님과 돈, 그리고 다단계 판매 (CBS 방송 칼럼) [16] 292115
7 ‘다단계’가 교회 망친다 “재원확보·선교” 명목 급속히 확산 [6] 600620
6 성도여 흔들리지 맙시다 /베뢰아사람 / 한국신학 [9] 604087
5 권사님이 다단계 판매조직 교회에 확장해 피해 커 국민일보 / 2012. 06. 28 [6] 703360
4 [살며 사랑하며-이근미] 바쁜 지금 봉사합시다 [6] 814241
3 또 다른 기독교인이 바라본 다단계에 관한 글 [9] 833026
2 어떤 기독교인이 바라본 다단계 판매에 관한 글 --- 싸이월드 [8] 903170
1 교회내 다단계 판매 어떻게 보십니까? [13] 925880
X
Login

브라우저를 닫더라도 로그인이 계속 유지될 수 있습니다. 로그인 유지 기능을 사용할 경우 다음 접속부터는 로그인을 하실 필요가 없습니다. 단, 게임방, 학교 등 공공장소에서 이용 시 개인정보가 유출될 수 있으니 꼭 로그아웃을 해주세요.

X