형제자매들

제목 없음

요.

maeip-0.jpg

 

교회가 다단계 판매업자들 '영업장'인가?

조회 수 53624 추천 수 0 2013.07.15 03:03:29

극성스럽게 물건 팔며 하부조직 구성하다 당회로부터 경고처분까지 받은 경우도 있어

뉴욕 퀸즈에 위치한 A 대형교회를 다니는 신모(51․ 여)씨는 언제부터인가 교회를 다니는 것이 스트레스로 다가오기 시작했다.

예배 후 친교시간이면 만나야 하는 다단계 물품 판매업에 종사하는 교인들 때문이다. 본인들은 ‘다단계업’이라고 하면 싫어하며 꼭 ‘네트워크 마케팅’이라고 불러달라고 한다.


하지만 신 씨는 “아무리 좋은 말을 갖다 붙여도 다단계가 확실한 것을 어찌하랴”고 생각한다.

신 씨는 “단기간 내에 고액을 벌 수 있다”말에 솔깃해 이들이 주최하는 세미나를 몇 번 참석 한 적도 있었다. 그러나 이들 말처럼 고액을 벌려면 모든 것을 포기하고 악착같이 여기에만 매달려야 하는데 신 씨는 그럴 자신이 없다.

최근 들어 다단계업에 대한 관심이 줄어들자 신 씨에 대한 다단계업자 교인들의 공세는 더욱 거세졌다.

“교회를 옮길까 생각해요. 다단계업자들의 유혹이 웬만한 교회의 전도활동보다 더 극성입니다. 이들이 좋다고 해서 사라는 물건은 거의 다 샀습니다만 내게 돌아오는 것은 몇 푼 안 되더라고요. 아래 단계 즉, 하부조직을 끊임없이 관리하며 물건을 팔고 조직원을 구성해야 합니다만 내게는 그럴 인맥과 능력이 없거든요. 이젠 일요일에 교회 가는 것이 지겨울 정도입니다”

불경기가 심화되자 교회마다 다단계업자들의 상술이 더욱 극성인 것으로 알려졌다.

이에 북부뉴저지 소재 C 교회의 경우에는 교인들을 상대로 지나친 상술을 발휘하며 스트레스를 주는 다단계업자 한 명을 최근 당회(堂會) 차원에서 경고조치 했다.

한번만 더 교인들로부터 항의가 더 접수되면 교회를 떠나달라는 내용이었다. 현재 한인사회에서 가장 많이 소개된 미국 다단계 회사는 Q사와 N사. 이 두 회사에 가장 많은 한인들이 다단계업에 종사하고 있다.

상당수 업자들은 남에게 별다른 피해를 주지 않는 반면 일부의 업자들의 상술은 도를 넘을 정도이다. 물건을 팔기 위해 거짓말도 서슴지 않는다. 또한 같은 교인임에도 불구하고 상대회사 업자에 대한 비난공세도 보통이 아니다.

롱아일랜드 모 교회 안수집사 박모(53)씨는 “상대방 업자에 대한 비난도 거세 교인들끼리 불신감을 조성하는 경우가 종종 있다”면서 “예전에는 보험업자들의 영업이 활발하더니 최근 몇 년간은 교회마다 다단계 업자들의 극성이 심하다”고 말했다.

뉴저지 N 교회의 경우는 작년 수차례에 걸쳐 다단계업자 교인들끼리 하부조직 구성을 놓고 말싸움을 벌여 몇 명의 교인이 교회를 떠나기도 했다.

익명을 요구한 이 교회의 R 장로는 “담임목사가 수년간 업자들에게 몇 차례 주의를 줬지만 말을 듣지 않았다”며 “평소 이들은 하나님을 믿으러 교회를 나오는 것인지 물건을 팔러 교회를 나오는 것인지 알 수가 없을 정도였다”라고 전했다.

이어 R 장로는 “교인들이 부동산업, 자동차판매업, 세탁업, 보험업 등 다양한 직업을 갖고 있지만 다단계 업자들만큼 극성스런 직업이 없다”며 “미국 본사에서 업자들에 대한 예절과 소양교육부터 시켜야 할 것”이라고 강조했다.

플러싱 모 교회 E 목사는 “한인사회의 크고 작은 교회를 막론하고 다단계업자들이 없는 경우는 없다”며 “부업으로 하는 교인들은 별다른 잡음이 없으나 다단계 판매업을 생업으로 삼고 있는 교인들 간에는 마찰음이 크다”고 말했다.

이들과 일반교인들 간의 마찰 중 가장 큰 이유는 다단계업자들이 교인들을 하부조직원으로 끌어들이기 전과 후의 언행이 너무 다르다는 것.

또한 고소득을 쉽게 올릴 수 있는 것처럼 과장되게 선전하며 교인들을 아래단계 조직원으로 구성한다는 점 등이다. 이밖에 “품질에 비해 가격이 너무 비싸다, 업자가 판매 가격을 속였다” 등의 불만도 터져 나오고 있는 실정이다.

Q사의 10년차 사업자 김모 씨는 “사업자들 중 일부가 문제를 일으키고 있는 점을 인정 한다”면서 “이들의 과장선전과는 달리 이 업종은 부업으로 고소득을 올릴 수 있는 직업이 아니다”라고 말했다.

이어 김 씨는 “많은 업자들이 1년에 1백만 달러 이상을 버는 고소득업자들을 ‘롤모델’로 제시하며 하부조직을 구성 한다”며 “그러나 그들은 끊임없는 성실과 인내, 겸손으로서 그 같은 위치에 오른 사람들이며 결코 단기간에 그 같은 수입을 올리지 않았다”라고 평했다.

현재 다단계 회사들은 일부 개인 사업자들의 문제점을 알고도 개선하려는 별다른 의지를 보이질 않고 있다.

3년간 이 업에 종사하다 지난 1월 그만 뒀다는 강모(뉴저지)씨는 “업자들 중 정말 성실하게 일하는 사람들도 있지만 그렇지 않은 사람들도 적지 않다”며 “때문에 친척들이나 지인들에게도 내가 이 업에 종사한다는 말을 그동안 못 하고 다녔다”고 말했다.

이어 강 씨는 “본사에서는 문제 사업자들에 대한 보고를 받고도 조치를 취하는 기색을 찾아 볼 수 없다”며 “이 업종은 단순하게 물건을 파는 것 보다 사람의 마음을 사는 행위라는 것을 망각하는 업자들이 종종 있다”고 덧붙였다.

제일 큰 문제점은 일부업자들이 교회 내에서 교인간의 분열을 조장하고 있다는 점이다.



▲ 일부 극성스런 다단계 업자들 때문에 한인사회의 적지않은 교회의 교인들이 많은 스트레스를 받고 있는 것으로 알려졌다. <사진은 본문의 특정기사와 관련없음>
플러싱 모 대형교회를 10년 넘게 다니다가 그만두고 지금은 다른 개척교회에 다니고 있다는 B 씨(55 ․ 여)는 “2년 넘게 다단계 업자의 감언이설에 속아 안 쫒아 다닌 모임과 세미나가 없을 정도”라며 지난날을 회상했다.

양 씨는 “결국 배신감만 남았다”며 “내가 상부조직원의 배만 불려주는 역할만 하고 있다는 사실을 알았을 때는 시간이 한참 흐른 후 였다”라고 말했다.

양 씨는 이어 “교회만 가면 만나게 되는 상부조직원의 모습이 보기 싫어 교회를 옮겼다”며 “지금도 그 상부조직원은 열심히 감언이설로 많은 교인들을 꼬드기고 있다”고 전했다.

이 문제와 관련 미동부한인기독교평신도협의회의 한 관계자는 “신성한 해야 할 교회가 특정 직업군의 영업장소로 전락 한 점에 대해 유감을 금할 수 없다”며 “이 문제가 계속해서 한인사회의 문제점으로

부각될 경우에는 교회협의회 등과 합동으로 다단계업자들이 소속된 미국본사에 항의서한을 보내는 등의 제재 조치를 강구 하겠다”고 말했다.

ㅁ 안상민 기자 -뉴욕 뉴스메이커


댓글 '7'

vuvanhon

2016.06.10 12:03:30

dự án chung cư hanhud là dự án bất động sản tốt ở khu vực tổng quan chung cư hanhud 234 hoàng quốc việt, chủ đầu tư chung cư hanhud là công ty Công ty Cổ Phần Kinh doanh Phát triển nhà và đô thị Hà Nội – HANHUD, với thiết kế mặt bằng chung cư hanhud khoa học, các căn hộ được bố trí khoa học và hợp phong thủy. 

William

2019.03.21 20:28:01

Nike mars yard Grey and black Vapormax Nike Air Max girls 2019 Air Jordan 6 retro Nike react hyperdunk 2019 black Cheap authentic Nike foamposite Nike Vapormax plus black Nike Air Max 97 reflect silver Adidas cloudfoam trainers Nike rn flyknit 2018 Adidas Originals NMD r1 men's Vapormax acronym Adidas store locator Yellow Huaraches womens Vapormax tan Mens Nike Air Max wright Air Force 1 foamposite white Adidas Originals 2019 Yeezys under 100 Adidas iniki black Are Christian Louboutins comfortable Adidas purechaos Asics gt 2000 trail women's Pandora pharmacy 2018 kobe shoes Adidas floral Womens retro Jordans Low Lebron 15 Nike fearless flyknit Nike tekno mk2 Nike flyknit racer red Lunarlon Nike womens shoes Adidas pharrell williams NMD NMD xr1 2019 Mens Adidas shell toe shoes Nike Air Force retro Adidas NMD mens black and white Sply 350 black Louboutin knee high boots Superstar usa Miami Ultra Boost Air Max plus red and black Adidas lifestyle shoes Pandora new york Nike trainers UK Adidas EQT adv black Pandora windmill charm Nike sneakers Peter moore Nike Nike free running shoes Nike Air Max sequent 2 men's NMD triple black Pandora es Nike flyease Adidas shoes for women 2019 Huarache shoe laces Jordan sneakers Nike evidence 2 White Nike shoes Off White bottoms Air Max 2019 Nike camouflage shoes Asics gel lyte iii Air Max 270 for kids Active Huarache shoes womens Iridescent Air Force 1 Ladies Air Max Nike air presto fly 2019 Pandora ohio Green bay packers Pandora charm Nike Air Max 90 junior Adidas Superstar holographic womens Nike uptempo 97 Asics noosa tri 11 2019 Yeezy 350 Mens Nike boots on sale Nike outlet jordans Nike Air Jordan xi boys Womens black Nike running shoes Nike Air Max 90 lx velvet Asics kayano 25 Nike react running Nike pigeon Blue and black Nikes Nike pegasus zoom 34 Roshes Nike Air Max plus black Camo af1 Nike Air Max plus womens Nike max 90 Mens Jordan trainers Tiffany blue Adidas Nike Air Max 98 Pandora sale 2019 New af1 Adidas 350 white navy Pandora horseshoe charm Lebron vi Pink Superstars Nike Air Max 90 ultra Vapormax sandals Upcoming Yeezy releases Nike trainers Pandora downtown Adidas iniki mens Nike flex rn 2019 women's Nike Air Jordan x Nike Huarache rainbow Mens Nike free rn flyknit 2019 Nike Air Max 2019 pink and white Nike men 2019 Adidas rainbow shoes Edge lux Adidas Comme des garcons Vapormax Nike Air Force 1 gum Grey Air Max 90 mens Black Air Max 97s Adidas Superstar shoes womens Jordan Air Max Nike Vapormax utility Adidas cloudfoam lite Pandora sterling silver rings Yeezy Boost grey Asics kayano trainer Rita ora Adidas trainers How to get the new Yeezys Pandora cord bracelet Nike dual fusion x2 mens Nike flyknit lunar 3 Air Max 90 grey Burgundy Huaraches womens Boys Huaraches High top Air Force ones Adidas EQT trainers Christian Louboutin houston Lady Pandora Goyard bag colors Nike Air Max 97 limited edition Human shoes Adidas Cheap real Yeezys Adidas caflaire trainers Nike tn Vapormax plus Black and grey Ultra Boost Pandora rings for kids Nike nba supreme Pandora estore Air Vapormax plus sunset Nike air uptempo Nike shoes 2019 new model Nike air 2019 kpu Nike Air Max plus jacquard Air Force 1 high 07 lv8 suede Adidas cloud Black and red 97 Air Max Nike lunarglide 7 Nike free run 2016 women's Nike flex Nike boys basketball shoes Air Max 270 brown Nike air mags for sale Louboutin platform sandals Air Force 1 equality Nike kobe xi Nike downshifter mens Christian Louboutin cinderella shoes Pandora elegance ring Asics youth wrestling shoes Ultra Boost chinese new year 2019 Red Nikes womens Toddler Air Force ones Nike kobe ad low Nike flyknit trainer 2019 white All black Nike shoes womens Lebron 12 red Yeezy Boost 350 v2 legit check Nike special edition shoes 2019 Nike Air Jordan xi girls Air Max 270 men Nike Air Force 1 sale Pandora Bracelet price Canada Nike latest model shoes 2019 Nike juvenate all black Nike Air Max size 8 mens Cheap Adidas shoes Kohls Adidas cloudfoam Easter Air Force ones 2019 Nike basketball shoes release Off White Air Max 97 release date Miadidas Ultra Boost Pandora disney summer 2019 Black Nike sneakers Adidas Ultra Boost triple white 2019 Adidas NMD tokyo Colorful Nike presto Air Max new 2019 New Adidas Yeezy 2019 Pandora coupon code Nike wholesale china Adidas NMD r1 triple black Off White Air Max 1 Black and white Huaraches Fairytale ring Pandora Nike griffey Nike Vapormax plus Nike Air Vapormax flyknit Adidas 350 Cream Vapormax Kids Ultra Boost Cowboys Nike shoes Nike in season tr 7 Nike air 270 womens Nike bakin boots Mens Air Max 2019 black Womens Adidas neo Camo Vapormax Red and white uptempo Jordan retro 11 red Red white and blue Adidas Nike zoom streak 6 Nike hyperdunk 2016 flyknit Adidas Ultra Boost women Nike mens training shoes Nike kobe xi boys Jordan 16 Bape NMD Off White vapor maxes Pandora rings Pandora beads Air Max 97 size 11 Disney Pandora 2019 Adidas high tops Womens Nike flex run 2019 Nike air more uptempo Nike benassi slides Jennifer lopez Louboutins Vapormax plus light menta Nike air zoom mariah flyknit racer Free running Pandora mesh bracelet Red Lebrons Chanel NMD Lebron James flip flops Asics womens walking shoes Nike Air Force Off White Pandora bible charm Yeezy drop Pandora jewelry nyc Vapormax shoes Swift Adidas Boys Nike school shoes Adidas tubular shadow women's Nike revolution 3 womens Nike promo code 2019 Nike outlet scotland All red Air Max plus Vapormax Nike Air Max 95 og black Off White Huaraches Asics women's gel kayano 21 running shoe Yeezy 1 zen Christian Louboutin open toe booties Future Yeezy releases 2019 Ebay UK Pandora charms Nike free transform flyknit Adidas duramo 7 Air Max 95 sale Nike town All black Nike Air Max 97 Black suede Adidas Pandora globe charm Nike Air Max 2016 black Jordan 12 womens Adidas promo code january 2019 Nike college discount disney Pandora spring 2019 Nike store locator Adidas crazylight Boost 2016 Womens Off White Presto Lebron s Nike slip proof shoes Adidas new release 2019 Adidas slip on kids Adidas chinese new year Air Force duckboot Nike coupon code december 2019 Nike flex 2019 rn mens Pandora flower ring Nike Kyrie 2 Adidas future releases Asics womens walking shoes Black Nike sandals Infant Nike Jordans Nike air Vapormax Flyknit moc black Air Force boots 2019 Nike vomero 14 Christian Louboutin peep toe Pandora green acres mall Nike Air Max 97 gold Nike zero Nike Air Huarache womens Air Max 98 all white Nike work boots Off White Jordan online Adidas memory foam sneakers Rare Pandora charms Pandora hawaii charm Cute Nike sneakers for women Womens teal Nike running shoes Pandora promo code Air Max plus kids Nike kobe nxt Nike Air Max 95 essential Mens Air Max Adidas NMD grey Nike utility Vapormax Air Force Nike kobe Nike flops Adidas NMD tri color Nike cycling shoes Air Max 89 Nike Air Jordan iii boys Nike roshe toddler girl Grey Vapormax plus Nike Air Max 2017 red Nike sb stefan janoski max l Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 Where is Pandora Pandora winiper charm Nike air uptempo Nike polka dot shoes Nike Air Jordan xiii Vapormax plus tropical sunset Sf af1 black Pandora cloud Adidas Superstar platform Womens white Adidas Pink Adidas trainers Vapormax moc black Yeezy Boost 350 v2 cream white Air Max 180 black Asics gel fit Nike zoom fly review Adidas winter boots womens with fur Pandora heart ring Yeezy Boost slippers Christian Louboutin lace heels Baby Yeezy Boost All black Nike sneakers mens NMD blue and white Jordans size 10 Adidas women fashion Air Max 95 khaki NMD_cs1 gtx primeknit shoes Asics brand Nike free run womens black Air Max 99 Supreme Nike shoes 2019 Pandora love necklace Pandora store near me Nike cortez Nike presto size 6 Nike flyknit trainer 2019 Gray Adidas sneakers Nike monarch iv

yolo

2019.03.29 15:56:55

coach outlet online

michael kors outlet clearance

michael kors outlet online

birkenstock sandals

ugg pas cher

pandora charms

ralph lauren uk

pandora charms outlet

canada goose coats

nike shoes

ralph lauren outlet online

ugg outlet

adidas outlet online

moncler jackets

eagles jersey

camisetas futbol baratas

yeezy shoes

moncler pas cher

supra shoes

air jordans

christian louboutin outlet

barcelona jersey

nike outlet store

juicy couture

pandora charms

ugg outlet clearance

coach factory outlet online

ugg outlet

louis vuitton outlet store

air huarache

michael kors outlet clearance

pandora outlet

fila shoes

canada goose outlet

uggs outlet

ferragamo belts

adidas yeezy boost 350

moncler outlet online

coach outlet

nike factory store

asics outlet

uggs outlet

ysl outlet

jordan pas cher

air max outlet

louboutin outlet

kate spade outlet

coach outlet canada

jordan shoes

pandora charms sale clearance

david yurman jewelry

jordan retro 11

ugg outlet store

chrome hearts outlet store

ralph lauren polo

nike outlet store online

phillies jerseys

raiders jerseys

nike sneakers

toms shoes

ed hardy outlet

gymshark clothing

jordan 12

coach outlet store online

pandora charms

true religion jeans

moncler jacka

coach outlet store

philipp plein outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet online

valentino

coach outlet online

polo outlet store

michael kors purse

oakley sunglasses wholesale

coach outlet store

mbt shoes

hydro flask lids

polo ralph lauren outlet

gucci bags

ed hardy

birkenstock outlet

north face outlet online

coach factory outlet

nike blazer

retro 11

asics running shoes

true religion jeans outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet online

yankees jerseys

匡威英国官网

air jordan shoes

coach factory outlet store

canada goose outlet store

nike hyperdunk

ed hardy

air jordan 4

air max

polo outlet store

coach factory outlet online

gucci outlet store

nike tn

buffalo bills jersey

patriots jerseys

jimmy choo shoes

denver broncos jersey

cheap jordan shoes

louis vuitton outlet online

coach factory outlet online

air max 2015

david yurman

cardinals jerseys

juicy couture

air jordan shoes

ed hardy shoes

coach outlet online

nike sneakers

coach outlet online

jimmy choo shoes

kate spade handbags

adidas nmd

louis vuitton

coach outlet online

instyler ionic styler

adidas nmd

christian louboutin outlet

nhl jerseys

ralph lauren outlet online

fitflops outlet

mbt shoes

gucci outlet online

mcm outlet store

true religion

bape hoodie

adidas outlet online

hydro flask sale

ugg boots women

coach outlet canada

louboutin outlet

fitflops

pandora sale clearance

true religion

guess clothing

soccer shoes

moncler jackets

nike shoes

pandora jewelry canada

coach outlet online

oakley sunglasses outlet

nike outlet online

david yurman

malone souliers shoes

nike outlet

pittsburgh steelers jersey

coach factory outlet online

ray ban sunglasses outlet

canada goose

pandora charms sale

balenciaga shoes

nike outlet online

ronaldo jerseys

ralph lauren polo

kate spade outlet

cheap nfl jerseys

hydro flask sale

air max 2017

christian louboutin shoes

puma shoes

durant shoes

coach outlet online

canada goose outlet

yeezy shoes

oakley outlet

coach outlet online

david yurman

brewers jerseys

ugg outlet

christian louboutin shoes

canada goose

converse shoes

coach outlet online

curry 5 shoes

adidas ultra boost

cheap air jordans

ralph lauren pas cher

kobe 11

the north face jackets

nobis outlet

persol sunglasses

coach factory outlet online

ralph lauren uk

miu miu shoes

jordan 31

coach canada outlet

nike max

adidas superstars

north face outlet store

ugg outlet sale

miu miu handbags

uggs

christian louboutin outlet

pandora jewelry outlet

ravens jerseys

coach outlet online

north face outlet

lebron 13

prada handbags

seattle seahawks jersey

mulberry bags sale

versace clothing

coach outlet online

rolex replica watches

cheap air max

jordan shoes for sale

rangers jersey

coach outlet online

lacoste outlet

coach outlet online

kate spade handbags

ferragamo outlet store

ralph lauren outlet online

new england patriots jersey

toms shoes

packers jersey

coach outlet store

coach factory outlet

coach factory outlet

coach outlet online

yeezy shoes

adidas nmd runner

uggs outlet

prada outlet online

cheap jordans

coach outlet

coach outlet clearance

coach outlet online

michael kors bags

coach outlet online

michael kors outlet online

pandora jewelry outlet

asics running shoes

coach outlet clearance

cheap snapbacks

coach outlet store online clearance

fitflops sale clearance

adidas ultra boost

kate spade outlet sale

under armour shoes

nike outlet

cheap jordan shoes

coach outlet online

pandora jewelry canada

yeezy shoes

north face outlet

ralph lauren uk

coach bags

coach factory outlet

pandora jewelry outlet

suicoke sandals

oakley sunglasses outlet

cheap air jordans

le coq sportif

columbia outlet store

true religion outlet

pandora jewelry outlet

cnaada goose outlet store

kate spade outlet online

polo ralph lauren outlet online

giuseppe zanotti outlet store

fjallraven kanken

fred perry

coach outlet store

discount oakley sunglasses

ugg boots outlet

devil rays jerseys

air max 2017

lacoste polo shirts

coach factory outlet online

coach outlet online

true religion outlet

coach outlet store

valentino outlet

snapback hats

minnesota vikings jersey

birkenstock outlet store

coach factory outlet

cheap mlb jerseys

michael kors outlet online

birkenstock shoes

ugg outlet

nike air force 1

pandora charms outlet

cheap soccer jerseys

converse英国官网

pandora outlet

pandora charms

jaguars jersey

kate spade outlet online

off white clothing

coach outlet online

kate spade outlet

fitflops sale clearance

kobe shoes

kate spade outlet store

true religion outlet store

nobis jackets

hermes bags

manolo blahnik outlet

chelsea jersey

coach outlet online

kobe shoes

coach factory outlet

foamposite shoe

ralph lauren outlet

mcm handbags

coach outlet online

yeti cup

pandora charms sale

coach factory outlet

coach factory outlet online

angels jerseys

ralph lauren outlet

yeti tumbler

christian louboutin outlet

chi flat iron

fivefingers shoes

pandora rings

adidas shoes

coach factorty outlet store

cheap jordans free shipping

nike free run

cheap maui jim sunglasses

true religion jeans

ed hardy

hermes

clarks

cheap snapbacks

air max 97

ralph lauren outlet

city royals jerseys

suicoke sandals

canada goose jackets

converse shoes

asics shoes

christian louboutin shoes

christian louboutin outlet

kendra scott

cubs jerseys

pandora charms sale clearance

michael kors outlet clearance

indianapolis colts jerseys

prada outlet

fitflops sale clearance

mbt shoes outlet

cardinals jerseys

nike kd 10

kyrie 2

coach outlet store

north face jackets

fitflops

nike free flyknit

converse shoes

canada goose coats

coach outlet online

air jordan 14

y3 shoes

canada goose sale

coach factory outlet online

coach outlet online

moncler outlet online

christian louboutin sale

stone island sale

michael kors outlet clearance

coach factory outlet online

fitflop sale

celine outlet

uggs outlet

cincinnati bengals jersey

mbt shoes

gucci outlet online

patriots jerseys

air jordan shoes

supreme clothing

coach factory outlet

coach outlet online

gucci outlet online

coach factory outlet online

balenciaga triples

michael kors outlet clearance

coach outlet store online

converse shoes

kate spade outlet online

michael kors bags

fitflops

prada outlet

nike outlet store

air max shoes

ugg boots

mbt shoes

mulberry handbags

timberland boots

air jordan retro

vans shoes

nike outlet online

ferragamo outlet

coach outlet clearance

cheap nike shoes

nike basketball shoes

air jordan 3

nike air max schweiz

prada outlet

yeezy shoes

fitflops sale clearance

fitflops

air max

uggs outlet

rolex replica watches for sale

nike factory store

kate spade

coach outlet online

lions jerseys

christian louboutin outlet

moncler sito ufficiale

nike roshe run

nba jerseys

true religion outlet

pandora charms outlet

ugg boots sale

pandora jewelry

true religion outlet store

nike outlet online

dodgers jerseys

michael kors handbags outlet

coach factory outlet online

cheap handbags

polo ralph lauren outlet

pandora canada

moncler

polo outlet

reds jerseys

coach factory outlet online

coach outlet canada

kate spade outlet online

michael kors outlet store

fitflops sale clearance

san diego chargers jerseys

michael kors outlet clearance

coach factorty outlet online

michael kors outlet online

diamondbacks jerseys

mac makeup

nike flip-flops

cheap mlb jerseys

mont blanc

polo ralph lauren outlet online

adidas outlet online

chaussures christian louboutin

cheap mbt shoes

louis vuitton purses

coach factory outlet

celine outlet

mac cosmetics

true religion jeans

coach factory outlet

coach outlet online

coach outlet store online

adidas wings

ugg boots

converse英国官网

pandora charms

birkin handbags

valentino outlet

vibram fivefingers outlet

kate spade outlet

nike air max 2018

ray ban sunglasses

jordan 4

louboutin outlet

true religion jeans

toms

maui jim

kendra scott

polo ralph lauren outlet

coach outlet online

louboutin outlet

nike outlet store

ubiq shoes

titans jersey

coach handbags

vans sneakers

giants jerseys

curry 4 shoes

coach outlet online

ed hardy outlet

dolce & gabbana Outlet

persol

ralph lauren polo

coach outlet online

coach outlet store online

stone island hoodie

yeezy boost 350

bathing ape

cheap jordan shoes

pandora jewelry outlet

costa sunglasses sale

birkenstock sandals

cheap jordans for sale

coach outlet store

ugg italia

kate spade handbags

adidas wings shoes

cheap snapbacks

adidas yeezy boost

canada goose coats

asics shoes

coach outlet online

ugg boots clearance

air max 2017

coach handbags

rolex watches

tigers jerseys

blue jays jerseys

pandora charms sale clearance

kate spade outlet online

nike outlet store

hydro flask cup

adidas outlet store

air max 270

nike air max 90

prada outlet

prada sunglasses

nike shoes

coach factory outlet

coach handbags clearance

adidas sneakers

adidas store

dolce & gabbana sunglasses

coach outlet

fitflops sale clearance

orioles jerseys

moncler outlet online

pandora charms

true religion outlet

cheap jordan shoes

mcm outlet

coach outlet online

coach outlet

michael kors outlet

cheap nfl jerseys

ecco outlet

fila

toms outlet store

michael kors outlet online

browns jerseys

falcons jerseys

polo ralph lauren outlet

ralph lauren outlet

ralph lauren outlet

nfl jerseys

adidas outlet

michael kors factory outlet

oakley sunglasses outlet

true religion jeans

nike air force

kevin durant shoes

michael kors outlet canada

air jordan shoes

nike factory store

adidas neo shoes

ugg boots

cowboys jerseys

cazal outlet

seahawks jerseys

moncler jacken

coach factory outlet

cheap jordan shoes

coach factory outlet

christian louboutin shoes

coach outlet online

jordan 12

persol sunglasses sale

valentino shoes

coach outlet store

nike outlet store

louboutin outlet

mlb jerseys

off-white clothing

louboutin outlet

coach outlet online

canada goose outlet

louboutin outlet

coach outlet store

coach factory outlet online

ugg italia

swarovski jewelry outlet

jordan 3

canada goose coats

cheap jordans

pandora outlet

white sox jerseys

coach outlet store

coach factory outlet online

david yurman bracelet

nike outlet online

revolution 3

coach outlet

jordans

michael kors outlet online

gucci outlet online

hermes outlet store

cheap jerseys

nike tn

cheap ray ban sunglasses

adidas nmd r1

red sox jerseys

canada goose

true religion jeans sale

air max plus

houston texans jerseys

coach factory outlet online

coach handbags outlet

stone island sale

red bottoms

giuseppe zanotti shoes

clarks shoes

coach outlet online

nike blazer

gymshark sale

coach handbags

mont blanc pen

off white clothing

christian louboutin

uggs outlet online

nba jerseys for sale

louboutin pas cher

birkenstock sandals

adidas uk

off white shirt

air jordan uk

coach outlet clearance

fred perry

swarovski crystal

coach outlet store online

superdry clothing

air max

broncos jerseys

ferragamo outlet

christian louboutin outlet

cheap ugg boots

kate spade outlet online

coach outlet sale

salomon shoes

coach outlet online

ralph lauren sale clearance uk

maui jim sunglasses

mlb jerseys

louis vuitton outlet online

pandora charms sale clearance

marlins jerseys

canada goose outlet store

michael kors outlet online

louboutin outlet

valentino outlet store

true religion outlet store

true religion outlet store

twins jerseys

true religion outlet store

uggs canada

pandora jewelry

converse shoes

coach bags

uboutin shoes

christian louboutin shoes

givenchy handbags

adidas yeezy boost

nike outlet store

michael kors outlet store

kate spade outlet online

north face outlet store

cheap jordans

rockies jerseys

jordan shoes

adidas slides

toms

canada goose coats

cheap jordan shoes

fitflops

coach outlet online

soccer jerseys

louboutin shoes

pandora jewelry store

saints jerseys

fitflops outlet

adidas shoes

pandora jewelry outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

adidas outlet store

ugg

adidas ultra boost

coach outlet sale

ugg boots

canada goose coats

air jordan

air max

costa sunglasses sale

pandora charms

kobe 12

michael kors outlet

pandora charms

coach purse

jets jersey

salvatore ferragamo shoes

vikings jerseys

michael kors outlet clearance

canada goose outlet store

air jordan retro

hermes belt

coach handbags

coach factorty outlet store

nike outlet

kappa clothing

gymshark sale

kate spade bags

oakley sunglasses outlet

christian louboutin sale

nike roshe

kendra scott

adidas yeezy shoes

hermes bags

air max pas cher

coach outlet online

uggs outlet

toms outlet online

parajumpers jacket

marc jacobs handbags

true religion outlet

yeti

coach outlet online

kate spade outlet

nike factory outlet

air jordan

nfl jerseys

fitflops outlet

ralph lauren polo

tods outlet online

jordans

moncler jackets

miu miu shoes

ddd

2019.04.09 09:54:09

<h1><a href="http://www.agespotsguide.org"><strong>nba tabellenstand</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.aktamichaelkorsvaska.se"><strong>michael kors rea</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.authenticnflonlinecheap.com"><strong>cheap nfl authentic jerseys</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.baratascamisetasdefutbolcomprar.es"><strong>todo camisetas futbol</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.baratascamisetasfutbolcomprar.es"><strong>equipacion atletico de madrid 2019</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.baratascamisetasfutbolcomprar.es"><strong>camisetas retro futbol</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.baratascomprarcamisetasdefutbol.es"><strong>comprar camisetas de futbol baratas</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.bibionebeachtriathlon.it"><strong>borse michael kors outlet</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.bibionebeachtriathlon.it"><strong>michael kors borse prezzi</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.bibionebeachtriathlon.it"><strong>michael kors borse outlet</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.bm-sities.com"><strong>nbaplus horarios</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.bm-sities.com"><strong>cfb3camisetas</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.borsemichaelkorsprezzioutlet.it"><strong>michael kors borse prezzi</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.bruchkoebler.de"><strong>wetter dortmund 16 tage</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.bruchkoebler.de"><strong>lsf fh dortmund</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.bruchkoebler.de"><strong>êbay</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.chalet-des-mousses.fr"><strong>mel ouvert caen</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.chalet-des-mousses.fr"><strong>heure de priere strasbourg 67200</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cheap-authenticjerseys.us"><strong>cheap authentic jerseys</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cheapcoachhandbag.us"><strong>coach crossbody bags on sale</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cheapcoachhandbag.us"><strong>coach outlet online clearance</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cheapcustom-shirts.com"><strong>cheap custom shirts</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cheapcustomshirtsnominimum.com"><strong>cheap custom t shirts no minimum</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cheapcustomshirtsonline.com"><strong>custom shirts online</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cheapestjerseysonline.us"><strong>cheap authentic nfl jerseys</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cheapestjerseysonline.us"><strong>authentic nfl jerseys</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cheaphumanhairwigsforsale.com"><strong>american girl doll wigs</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cheaphumanhairwigsforsale.com"><strong>american girl doll wigs cheap</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cheapiphonecasesonsale.com"><strong>cheap custom phone cases</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cheapjerseys2018.us"><strong>cheap nfl jerseys from china</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cheapjerseysonline2018.com"><strong>cheap jerseys online</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cheapjerseysonlinesale.us"><strong>stubhub miami heat</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cheaplacewigsonlineoutlet.com"><strong>cheap wigs online</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cheapnflshopjerseys.com"><strong>cheap nfl jerseys</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cheapnhlshop.org"><strong>cheap nhl jerseys</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cheapralphlaurenoutletonliesale.com"><strong>cheap ralph lauren shirts online</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cheapt-shirtdesign.com"><strong>flannel bridesmaid shirts</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.coachfactoryoutletonlinecheap.com"><strong>coach purses on clearance</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.coachonlineonsalefactory.com"><strong>coach factory online sale invitation</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.coachstoreonlinecheap.com"><strong>coach factory outlet online login</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.coachstoreonlinecheap.com"><strong>official coach factory outlet online</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.comprarcamisetasbaratasdefutbol.es"><strong>camisetas de marca baratas originais</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.comprarcamisetasfutbol-baratas.es"><strong>camisetas futbol falsas online</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.crl-bretagne.fr"><strong>2siteweb</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.customcheapphonecases.com"><strong>cheap custom phone cases</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.customphonecasescheap.com"><strong>lgl82vl phone cases</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.customphonecasescheap.com"><strong>zte zmax pro custom case</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.customtshirtsonline.net"><strong>cheap lace front wigs</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.cutecheapphonecases.com"><strong>cell phone cases wholesale</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.essenturm.de"><strong>wetter leipzig 16 tage</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.factoryonlinecoach.com"><strong>coach factory outlet online</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.factoryonlinecoach.com"><strong>coach outlet online</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.factoryonlinecoach.com"><strong>coach bags factory outlet</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.factoryoutletonlinecoach.com"><strong>cheap coach purses</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.factoryoutletonlinecoach.com"><strong>coach bags for cheap</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.factoryoutletonlinecoach.com"><strong>coach factory outlet online</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.fulllacewigscheap.com"><strong>tupay wig</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.fulllacewigscheap.com"><strong>rosewholesale wigs</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.gaverland.it"><strong>infoclick anm</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.gaverland.it"><strong>prefisso 045</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.humanhairextensionscheap.com"><strong>cheap human hair wigs</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.internationalartconsultants.fr"><strong>mel ouvert caen</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.internationalartconsultants.fr"><strong>celtic psg streaming</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.louboutinpascherhomme.fr"><strong>vertbaudet chaussures filles</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.louboutinpascherhomme.fr"><strong>modatoi chaussures compensées</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.maglienba2018.it"><strong>nba sportando</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.mp45workoutprogramreview.com"><strong>stsl tabellenstand</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.mp45workoutprogramreview.com"><strong>max von helldorff</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.nflshopjerseyscheap.com"><strong>nfl shop jerseys</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.nflwholesaleonlinejerseyscheap.com"><strong>nfl jerseys wholesale</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.paschermaillotfoot.fr"><strong>maillot boca junior</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.paschermaillotnba.fr"><strong>maillot asse pas cher</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.personalisedtshirts.net"><strong>cheap best friend shirts</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.phptostart.it"><strong>calciomercatonapoli24</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.prezziborsemichaelkors.it"><strong>michael kors borse saldi</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.prezziborsemichaelkors.it"><strong>borse michael kors saldi</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.ralphlaurenonlinestorecheap.com"><strong>polo ralph lauren outlet online</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.ralphlaurenshoponlineoutlet.com"><strong>polo ralph lauren factory store</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.reamichaelkorsvaska.se"><strong>michael kors plånbok</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.recordpizzamen.it"><strong>forum napolimagazine</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.salebagscoachoutletonline.com"><strong>coach outlet online</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.salecoachhandbagsoutlet.com"><strong>www coachoutlet com</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.salecoachhandbagsoutlet.com"><strong>official coach factory outlet online</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.salecoachhandbagsoutlet.com"><strong>coach factory outlet online login</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.salecoachoutletbags.com"><strong>www coachoutlet com</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.salecoachoutletbags.com"><strong>coach outlet coupon</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.salecoachoutletbags.com"><strong>official coach factory outlet online</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.simplysweetbuffets.com"><strong>nba store eu</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.streetdeal.de"><strong>besoldungsrechner</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.streetdeal.de"><strong>besoldungsrechner bayern</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.thecatsblog.com"><strong>polo jogging suits</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.thecatsblog.com"><strong>polo ralph lauren outlet online</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.uptownmarketjax.com"><strong>retro nba jerseys cheap</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.webbrainnet.it"><strong>borse michael kors outlet</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.webbrainnet.it"><strong>michael kors borse outlet</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.wholesalenflonlinecheap.com"><strong>cheap nfl jerseys</strong></a></h1>
<h1><a href="http://www.vaskordammichaelkors.se"><strong>michael kors plånbok</strong></a></h1>

DDD

2019.04.09 09:55:20

nba tabellenstand

michael kors rea

cheap nfl authentic jerseys

todo camisetas futbol

equipacion atletico de madrid 2019

camisetas retro futbol

comprar camisetas de futbol baratas

borse michael kors outlet

michael kors borse prezzi

michael kors borse outlet

nbaplus horarios

cfb3camisetas

michael kors borse prezzi

wetter dortmund 16 tage

lsf fh dortmund

êbay

mel ouvert caen

heure de priere strasbourg 67200

cheap authentic jerseys

coach crossbody bags on sale

coach outlet online clearance

cheap custom shirts

cheap custom t shirts no minimum

custom shirts online

cheap authentic nfl jerseys

authentic nfl jerseys

american girl doll wigs

american girl doll wigs cheap

cheap custom phone cases

cheap nfl jerseys from china

cheap jerseys online

stubhub miami heat

cheap wigs online

cheap nfl jerseys

cheap nhl jerseys

cheap ralph lauren shirts online

flannel bridesmaid shirts

coach purses on clearance

coach factory online sale invitation

coach factory outlet online login

official coach factory outlet online

camisetas de marca baratas originais

camisetas futbol falsas online

2siteweb

cheap custom phone cases

lgl82vl phone cases

zte zmax pro custom case

cheap lace front wigs

cell phone cases wholesale

wetter leipzig 16 tage

coach factory outlet online

coach outlet online

coach bags factory outlet

cheap coach purses

coach bags for cheap

coach factory outlet online

tupay wig

rosewholesale wigs

infoclick anm

prefisso 045

cheap human hair wigs

mel ouvert caen

celtic psg streaming

vertbaudet chaussures filles

modatoi chaussures compensées

nba sportando

stsl tabellenstand

max von helldorff

nfl shop jerseys

nfl jerseys wholesale

maillot boca junior

maillot asse pas cher

cheap best friend shirts

calciomercatonapoli24

michael kors borse saldi

borse michael kors saldi

polo ralph lauren outlet online

polo ralph lauren factory store

michael kors plånbok

forum napolimagazine

coach outlet online

www coachoutlet com

official coach factory outlet online

coach factory outlet online login

www coachoutlet com

coach outlet coupon

official coach factory outlet online

nba store eu

besoldungsrechner

besoldungsrechner bayern

polo jogging suits

polo ralph lauren outlet online

retro nba jerseys cheap

borse michael kors outlet

michael kors borse outlet

cheap nfl jerseys

michael kors plånbok

문서 첨부 제한 : 0Byte/ 2.00MB
파일 제한 크기 : 2.00MB (허용 확장자 : *.*)
List of Articles
번호 제목 조회 수
공지 교회 내에서 행해지는 다단계 --- 한국장로신문 [4] 49790
공지 교회는 장사하는 곳이 아니다. / 김정태(베뢰아대학원대학교 신약학 교수) update [6] 64268
공지 다단계 판매와 교회( 그리스도인의 직업으로 적합한가 외...) file [1] 33890
18 어떤 기독교인이 바라본 다단계 판매에 관한 글 --- 싸이월드 [2] 37501
17 성도여 흔들리지 맙시다 /베뢰아사람 / 한국신학 [1] 44372
16 교회내 다단계 판매 어떻게 보십니까? [1] 50138
15 [살며 사랑하며-이근미] 바쁜 지금 봉사합시다 [1] 51935
14 또 다른 기독교인이 바라본 다단계에 관한 글 [8] 52074
13 어떤 기독교인이 바라본 다단계에 관한 글 (암웨이등...) update [6] 52721
» 교회가 다단계 판매업자들 '영업장'인가? [7] 53624
11 [교회와 이단] 373 - 다단계에서 인간관계 형성의 문제점 [4] 54340
10 다단계에 신도 2만8000명 끌어들인 목사들 [3] 54904
9 월 1,000 만원의 허황된 꿈 / 흩어지는 교회 [2] 55474
8 다단계 판매업 종사자에 대하여 지도자들이 취해야 할 입장 / 예수그리스도 후기성도교회 (몰몬교 개인사이트에서) [2] 55624
7 다단계 판매에 대한 기독교 윤리적 비판 [1] 56697
6 교회 안에서 다단계에 대해(암웨이) / 모교회홈피에서 [3] 59356
5 다단계하는 하는 년들은 보아라 [3] 61698
4 다음에서 퍼온 기독교인이 본 다단계 [1] 65887
3 ‘다단계’가 교회 망친다 “재원확보·선교” 명목 급속히 확산 [1] 68903
2 하느님과 돈, 그리고 다단계 판매 (CBS 방송 칼럼) [2] 69280
1 권사님이 다단계 판매조직 교회에 확장해 피해 커 국민일보 / 2012. 06. 28 [1] 90332
X
Login

브라우저를 닫더라도 로그인이 계속 유지될 수 있습니다. 로그인 유지 기능을 사용할 경우 다음 접속부터는 로그인을 하실 필요가 없습니다. 단, 게임방, 학교 등 공공장소에서 이용 시 개인정보가 유출될 수 있으니 꼭 로그아웃을 해주세요.

X