형제자매들

제목 없음

요.

maeip-0.jpg

 





 기사수정
 성도여 흔들리지 맙시다흩어지는 교회
 
김창주 기자

다단계판매가 기독교회에 주는 해악은? 성도들이 어떤 직업관과 물질관을 가져야 하는지 알아보자

문명이 발전함에 따라 돈은 기본적인 인간생활을 영위하는 데 있어 없어서는 안 될 중요한 요소가 되었다. 돈을 버는 목적도 의·식·주의 해결에 있지 않고 보다 나은 문화생활을 영위하려는 데 있다. 그에 따라 돈이면 다 된다는 물질만능주의가 팽배해졌다. 
사람들은 이제 어떻게 하면 ‘쉽게 돈을 벌 수 있을까’를 고민한다. 다단계 판매원 수가 급증하는 현상은 그 단적인 예다. 
그런데 놀라운 사실은 판매원 수의 40∼45%가 기독교인이라는 것이다. 종로 YMCA 시민중계실의 김희경 간사는 다단계 판매원 중 기독교인이 차지하는 실제 비율은 80%에 이른다고 밝혀 더 큰 충격을 던져주었다. 
이는 한국교회가 상업주의와 물질만능주의에 심각하게 노출돼 있음을 보여주는 것이다.

그리스도인이 다단계 판매에 솔깃해지는 이유
그리스도인은 바쁘다. 24시간을 쪼개 영적생활과 일상생활을 동시에 책임지고 영위해야 하기 때문에 늘 시간에 쫓기며 산다. 그렇다고 누가 생계문제를 해결해 주는 것도 아니기에 짧은 시간에 많은 돈을 버는 일에 쉽게 솔깃해진다. 
특히 그리스도인은 더 많은 물질로 하나님께 헌신하기 원하고, 할 수만 있다면 더 많은 시간을 하나님께 봉사하고 싶어 한다. 그래서 직장을 선택할 때도 주일에 근무하지 않는 직장을 찾으려 노력하고, 가능하면 수요예배, 금요철야 기도회 같은 모임에 빠지지 않고 참석할 수 있을 정도로 시간 사용에 자유가 있는 직장을 선호한다.
이러한 그리스도인의 심리 때문에 쉽게 빠져드는 직종이 다단계 판매업이다. 우선 사업설명회만 들어보면 돈도 많이 벌 수 있고, 많은 시간을 하나님을 위해 봉사할 수 있을 것 같기에 이는 더없이 매력적으로 비춰진다. 그래서 많은 그리스도인이 다단계 판매원으로 활동하고 있다. 이에 대해 YMCA 시민중계실의 김희경 간사는 ‘다단계 판매방식과 교회의 구역·교구 조직이 끈끈한 인간관계로 얽혀 있다는 점에서 매우 흡사하기 때문’이라고 분석한다.
이대우 목사(서울성락교회 목회협력실장)는 교인들이 다단계를 하게 되는 근본 원인이 “잘못된 물질관 및 노동관에 있다”고 전제하고 “하나님은 물질의 많고 적음을 보시는 것이 아니라 마음의 중심을 보시는 분임을 깨달아야 한다”고 권면한다.
처음에 그리스도인들이 다단계 판매에 쉽게 쏠리는 이유는 짧은 시간에 많은 돈을 벌 수 있어 자기 시간을 많이 확보할 수 있다는 생각 때문이다. 하지만 실제로 그리스도인들에게 돌아오는 것은 영적·정신적·물질적 피해 뿐이다.
우선 다단계 판매원들은 온전한 주일성수를 하기 어렵다. 새로운 하부 판매원을 만들어 자신의 위치를 높여 가야 하기 때문에 일반인들이 유일하게 쉬는 날인 주일(일요일)은 황금의 시간인 것이다. 그 때문에 예배가 끝나기 무섭게 쏜살같이 사람을 데리고 사업설명회 장소로 간다.
그러다 보니 봉사는 어느새 뒷전이 되어 버리고 만다. 자신에게 돈이 되는 하부 판매원을 만드는 것이 유일한 관심사가 되어 버린 것이다. 또 어떤 다단계 업체(예: 암웨이)는 보다 많은 신입 판매원을 확보하기 위해 기독인 다단계 판매원들을 주일에 단체로 모여 예배를 드리고 그 즉시 업무에 투입하기도 한다. 이럴 경우, 몸된 교회를 위해 봉사할 기회는 완전히 사라지는 것이다. 

영적으로 무익한 다단계 판매
교회 안에 다단계 판매원의 수가 증가할수록 성도간의 불협화음이 늘어나 사실상 구역과 교구 조직이 원활히 이루어지기 어렵게 된다. 본래 구역예배나 교구예배는 예배하고 간증하며 동역자들의 믿음을 독려하는 데 존재목적이 있다. 그러나 구역장이나 교구장이 다단계 판매원인 경우, 모임은 하위 판매원을 늘려가는 사업장이 되기 쉬워 그 구역과 교구가 받게 될 영적인 손상은 무시할 수 없다. 
성도들은 영적인 리더(구역장, 교구장, 전도사, 목사)가 지시하면 100% 순종하도록 배우고 양육받는다. 왜냐하면 자신의 리더를 하나님이 세우셨다고 인정하기 때문이다. 그러나 만일 리더의 요구가 영적인 것이 아니기 때문에 순종하지 않고 거부하면 갈등이 일어나게 된다. 결국 구역원들과 교구원들 사이에 끈끈한 유대관계가 깨지고 만다.
실제로 얼마 전 경기도 성남시에 있는 S교회의 이모씨는 자신의 구역장 직분을 이용하여 구역 식구들에게 홈쇼핑과 다이너스티 회원에 가입해 줄 것을 강요한 일이 있었다. 그로 인해 무리를 빚는 등 구역 식구들과의 잦은 충돌로 교회의 분열을 초래했던 것으로 드러났다. 결국 이모씨와 함께 교회 교인들을 대상으로 네트워크 다단계 판매조직을 형성하여 한 몫을 챙기려 했던 무리들은 교회를 떠났다고 한다.
전도사나 목사 등 목회자가 다단계 판매원인 경우, 그 피해는 더욱 심각하다. 목회자는 하나님의 피로 사신 영혼들을 주님 앞에 설 때까지 말씀 안에서 양육하는 성직을 맡은 자다. 그런데 목회자가 그 본연의 책무를 망각하고 하늘의 영원한 상급 대신 오히려 물질을 좇는 자로 이끈다면 그 결과가 어떠하겠는가? 결국 그를 따르는 수많은 성도들을 혼란에 빠뜨리고 말 것이다. 그런데 이러한 가정이 현실로 드러남으로 인해 그 심각성을 말해주고 있다.
실제로 SMK(숭민 코리아 종합유통 대표 임정수)라는 다단계 업체는 장로가 회장으로 있고, 소속 판매원 가운데 300여 명이 현직 목회자라고 한다. 얼마 전에는 서울 신림동 소재 B교회의 담임 목회자인 K목사(다이너스티인터내셔널 판매원)가 다이너스티 판매방식을 교인들 앞에서 강조하는 현장이 목격되어 교계에 큰 파문을 일으킨 바 있다. 
K목사는 교인들이 모인 공개적인 자리에서 “우리가 이렇게 초라한 예배당에서 교육관도 없이 예배드릴 수 있겠느냐?”며 “다이너스티 판매조직을 잘 운영하면 보다 좋은 환경의 예배당을 지을 수 있고, 이는 우리 교회의 부흥으로 이어질 수 있다”는 발언을 서슴지 않은 것으로 밝혀졌다. 더 나아가 K목사는 구역장을 다이너스티 판매 팀장으로 세우는 등 교회조직을 돈벌기 위한 상업적 수단으로 만들어가고 있다. 한 목회자가 잘못된 물질관 내지 신앙관을 가졌을 경우, 어떤 결과를 초래할 수 있는지를 잘 보여주는 경우다.
이처럼 다단계 판매를 하는 이들이 교회 안에 자리를 잡게 되면 교회의 본래 목적을 상실할 우려가 있다. 교회의 목적은 영혼을 구령하고 성도들에게 하늘의 소망을 심어주는 데 있다. 그런데 교인들이 다단계 판매원이 되면 같은 구역과 교구 식구들의 친분관계를 이용해 조직원화시킴으로 그 모임은 영적인 순수성을 잃게 된다. 결국, 구역모임은 하나님의 말씀보다 돈 버는 법에 쏠리게 된다.
이에 대해 한세대학교 조귀삼 교수는 “현재 한국 기독교가 교단과 교파를 초월해 다단계 판매방식의 심각성을 인식하고 대비하지 않으면 그 피해는 교회 내 성도들과 한국 기독교로 돌아갈 것은 불을 보듯 뻔하다”고 하여 시급한 대책 마련을 촉구했다(교회연합신문, 2002년 2월 3일자). 물질이 우상이 되는 말세지말에(딤후 3:1, 2) 성경에서 경고한 것처럼 물질을 좇지 말고 자신의 영혼과 교회를 위해 정신을 차려야 한다.

 

     ▲     


Copyright ⓒ 2000 BAC
379-5, Shinkil 5-dong, Seoul, Korea
Telephone 070-7300-6715ㅣFax 02-844-3875
E-mailㅣ lightshineⓐnate.com


댓글 '4'

Sjcg123

2017.04.17 11:53:01

TOMS OUTLET

canada goose jacket outlet

hogan scontate

converse store

Yeezy Men

suivre un envoi

Moncler Outlet Store

Toms Outlet Online

Adidas Superstar Sale Online

Nike Shox Cheap

Toms Factory Outlet

Cheap Air Max Trainers

newest lebron shoes

Nike Soccer Cleats Boots

Pandora Store Sale

christian louboutin outlet

adidas outlet

Yeezy Black

Ugg Pas Cher En France

prada outlet

Air Max Kopen

Nike Tn Requin Pas Cher

new pandora charms

TOMS For Sale

Cheap Toms Shoes Outlet

Nike Air Women

nike air jordan pas cher

zapatillas nike baratas

Nike Air Damen

zapatos de futbol nike

Yeezy Shoes Discount Marketplace

UGG BOOTS FOR WOMEN

Ugg boots Sale

pandora beads

Ray ban sale online

billige nike sko

womens nike air max

coach factory outlet online

longchamp bags on sale

Canada Goose Outlet

cheap nike air max

Chaussure Air Max

Air Max Sneakers

Adidas Originals Stan Smith

nike schuhe günstig

Ray Ban Sunglasses Online

Air max dam

moncler jacket sale

Discount Air Max

Original Ugg Boots

Nike Air Jordan 11

Cheap Michael Kors Tote Bag

ADIDAS NMD SALE ON LINE

Adidas Neo Discount Sale

nike air

Vans Black Sneakers

Doudoune Moncler Pas Cher

Michael Kors Outlet

air force one pas cher

Air Max Femme

Nike Shoes Discount Marketplace

Cheap Michael Kors

toms shoes outlet

Jordan Shoes Air

chaussures nike pas cher

goedkope nike air max

chaussure basket homme

scarpe hogan outlet

Michael Kors Handbags Discount

Air max levně

Canada Goose Womens Coats

louboutin heels

Doudoune Moncler Site Officiel

nike sneakers

Ugg Pas Cher Femme

cheap uggs for women

Air Max Pas Cher

Adidas Originals Superstar

Michael Kors Clearance

pandora outlet store

Nike Shoes Sale Store

adidas store

Pandora Store

ugg store

Stone Island Outlet

zapatillas running

Air Nike

Moncler Jackets Discount Marketplace

günstige nike schuhe

botas de futbol

pandora jewelry store

reebok running shoes

new yeezy shoes

Canada Goose Outlet

Pandora Store

Negozi Pandora

retro jordans for cheap

official NHL jerseys

canada goose jackets on sale

Adidas Superstar

abercrombie and fitch store

huarache sneakers

Air Max 90

Boost Yeezy Sale On Line

Nike Air Huarache For Sale

Nike Factory Store

Adidas Shoes Discount Marketplace

Nike Air Sneakers

Moncler Outlet Online

scarpe nike

Nike Zapatos

nike tn pas cher

ugg factory outlet

vans shoe store

Nike Online Store

Cheap Toms Outlet Store

Jordan Sneakers For Sale

Nike Shox discount Sale

Nike Air Pas Cher

new jordan releases

Ugg Outlet Online Store

nike joggesko

Timberland Outlet

Air Jordan Retro Sale

nike air max running shoes

Boutique Ugg

Kobe Shoes Nike

nfl store

nike jordan shoes

Yeezy Boost Sale Online

nike mercurial soccer cleats

Ray-Ban Official Discounted Site

Boty Nike Air

Nike Roshe Run Sale

Oakley Sunglasses Cheap

nike shoes

fitflops sale uk

Coach Bags On Sale

Discount TOMS

Nike Air Max Cheap

Nike Store

ugg clearance

Michael Kors

Pandora Official Website

TOMS SHOES OUTLET

Nike Air 90

Uggs Pas Cher Soldes

Bottes Ugg Femme Pas Cher

chaussure Nike homme

Canada goose dam

zapatilla adidas

Uggs For Cheap

Jordan Schoenen

Soccer Boots Outlet nike

23 IS BACK Store

Chaussure Nike Air Max Pas Cher

nike sb stefan janoski

Scarpe Air Max

Jordan Store

Descuentos Nike

Hogan Outlet

Moncler Sale

Hugo Boss Sale

toms sale

nike sportschuhe

Official Toms Shoes Outlet

Nike Pas Cher Femme

cheap uggs

Nike Air Max Goedkoop

Doudoune Moncler Femme Pas Cher

Nike Outlet

0417Sjcg

whn

2017.04.22 11:30:08

Suddenly scarpe hogan feel the polo ralph lauren outlet life of ua stephen curry a sudden, desolate like a summer chicago bulls sun north face blowing the wind of polo ralph lauren outlet online the winter, prada outlet cold michaelkors.com to the bottom of my ray ban outlet heart but kept hollister co sweating, little michael kors bags by little, nike air drop by drop, soaked the cheap oakley chapped wound, relojes especiales the pain toms outlet is no longer longchamp outlet Know what is vans shoes the pain, and sometimes even tory burch shoes feel pandora that nike.de the pain of nike tn requin this skin nfl vikings is true religion nothing to do with me, even air jordan shoes if the pain to my jordan shoes teeth; but ralph lauren black friday the heart still will not nfl 49ers say to louboutin outlet their mouth sorry, that is new balance what kind of denver nuggets acceptable, no big deal; I really givenchy bags outlet do burberry handbags not sac jerseys know jerseys from china this fearless strong ralph lauren factory store or cheap true religion corpses adidas superstar debauchery; people look like a tommy hilfiger outlet stores humanoid rayban on nike air force the utah jazz case board nfl texans was burberry uk wantonly slaughtered, but pistons jersey also thought it was singing anyway is salomon schuhe not another form of bottega veneta existence, oakley outlet online but also nfl browns Ashes polo ralph lauren So ear to someone barbour mens jackets said, mature, not a very realistic change, but to accept p90x workout schedule the nike huaraches reality, hollister kids this philosophical orlando magic words I entered mbt shoes outlet into milwaukee bucks the thought. Xicheng summer russell westbrook jersey is very hot, all ralph lauren uk the people in the dre beats air is burberry online shop like a louboutin shoes magic coach factory outlet online lead hooded shrouded, was pinched nike.com into nike air a mud, only sweat in the ray ban black friday silence of the silent north face pas cher interpretation of polo outlet online this tight mix of mud for the additive, the earth is knicks jerseys never stop the fire Kiln, and we dallas mavericks jersey are that wrapped asics in the prada outlet hot nike air max furnace hogan baked hollister in the mud salvatore ferragamo pottery, in time and a certain degree of pandora tacit cheap glasses understanding with a michael kors bags certain coach bags type, and then become a man to play porcelain, but also in a casual, hear a cry chrome hearts jewelry Crisp sound of the accompaniment, playing a michael kors handbags scene jerseys from china of splashing nike roshe splash, heartbreak of the sound timberland boots around flat iron the north face outlet wall, the opening roshe run of this katespade outlet season's fierce. burberry handbags Woke up, opened his toms shoes eyes, the other parts are moving did hilfiger not move, into my line polo ralph of sight is nike free 5.0 going to sleep is about nike free run to land cheap ray ban Gillian, bcbg dresses she was lying on the bed asleep, mouth ray bans saliva also kept in coach outlet online the sheets ralph lauren outlet online In the slightest dipped in dsquared2 shoes the circle of wet lines burberry are clothing websites also constantly fighting burberry bags outlet to lunette oakley pas cher spread, that white nike air max 2014 bones adidas.de of the cold kevin durant shoeskobe bryant shoes bed sheets to let ralph lauren the difference plein outlet surprised, occhiali oakley my heart began to timberland shoes ask myself dsquared2 jeans where is this, but also nfl panthers thought coach outlet he was dreaming, the roshe run body A little move, ray ban sunglasses the nfl jerseys foot of a pain hit, wholesale handbags so he saw himself wrapped into dumplings feet. All the memories and rayban sunglasses stories with the pain nfl ravens gradually kicked giuseppe zanotti off. I carefully relieved polo ralph lauren his juicy couture feet ray ban sunglasses with both hands, huaraches give it a fendi outlet online little prada comfortable place soccer shoes to find another indiana pacers posture, then ray-ban sunglasses Gillian woke up, has not earned red bottoms his eyes, mouth los angeles clippers saliva with adidas.se her cheap oakley sunglasses head lift, nfl buccaneers be baseball bats " Flying down three thousand feet, "and roshes she rubbed longchamp taschen his eyes, looked toms shoes outlet at me with swarovski jewelry her fingers, michael kors outlet online suddenly came out, wiped the saliva by air max 2015 hand. nfl raiders "Luoxi, free running now the ferragamo shoes pain iphone 4s cases is tommy hilfiger not cheap oakley sunglasses a good ferragamo point?" nfl giants Yuejiao quickly replica rolex sit and hold my hand. mcm bags I was portland trail blazers stretched past two oakley hands on nike free shoes her hand back, houston rockets gently nfl jets patted her, michael kors black friday expressed to minnesota timberwolves let her feel at suns jerseys ease, oakley black friday do not hurt, I do nfl falcons not know how nike air max to do it! michael kors bags Obliterate the mouth, and kanye west shoes then nfl broncos smile with each other. "It's all right, you air max see your nop jerseys feet san antonio spurs are like this, when the doctor gave air max 2014 you anesthetic, nfl cowboys not serious instyler ionic styler will play air max Well, really, when swarovski australia my child!" She leaned kate spade outlet online to my true religion outlet eyes, cheap basketball shoes with a ralph lauren Eyes staring at vans outlet me, it barbour mens jackets is nfl titans natural to show a ed hardy clothing elders like my love. michael kors bags "Oh, almost forgot!" She was shocked, "I gave you a bone soup, mizuno running shoes you beats by dre try to see if christian louboutin shoes you can think of anything!" Quickly burberry outlet online got up and walked charlotte hornets jersey to my new balance bedside table next wedding dresses uk to open the puma eater, mcm outlet but also braved the tommy hilfiger online shop heat It, michael kors bags with the adidas shoes outlet hot air floated, nfl saints taste really longchamp fragrant. gsw jerseys I first drank bottega the chi hair soup, so familiar taste, but suddenly anxious celine handbags to converse shoes remember. "How about jimmy choo shoes you, Luoxi? ralph lauren uk No, you kobe bryant jersey can not think adidas neo of anything! You have nike.dk no conscience oakley prescription Yeah?" Gillian's replica handbags three hollister online shop deutschland surprised mcm handbags surprised expression montre pas cher with a tone air jordan than michael kors outlet online a strong, let me coach factory outlet online think she has some Hate me, nba jerseys as if regret to eat me, cheap oakley or feel that ray ban sunglasses outlet I ray ban sunglasses eat and ruined. "Oh, this timberland homme taste I am too familiar with, philadelphia 76ers jersey let oakley sunglasses cheap me think about michael kors handbags it!" michael kors australia I spoiled, to burberry sale discuss giuseppe shoes her, holding a air max shoes spoon tightly, cheap nike shoes holding, asics gel afraid bcbg max azria she really jordans for sale left me, let toms outlet me Enjoy, kate spade outlet but that designer handbags is tommy hilfiger not to speak, toms shoes all my own to SUDDEN coach purses DEATH. the north face "You can not nfl bengals remember, you designer handbags do not eat, eat!" nike outlet She finally said I air jordans thought, "you let me speechless!" ray ban She said a look oakley sunglasses outlet of grievances. "Oh, oh nfl patriots ... fake rolex I think of nfl colts it!" I have not said that iphone 5 cases she has juicy couture clothings received: "Do not louboutin you think longchamp of a man, your mother, did not nfl steelers think of the taste of home! If you can nike outlet not burberry outlet online remember, I oakley sunglasses outlet really For her abercrombie aunt cheap jerseys is not toms outlet worth! "She wanted to longchamp handbags shoot jimmy choo me, prada handbags the handle was lively, and nfl packers see coach black friday that posture, I quickly pointed tory burch sandals to my feet, nfl chargers she armani clothing was hand. "Thank you, Gillie!" replica watches I left memphis grizzlies the bowl slightly raised against ray ban zonnebril her, right hand quickly with a spoon pointing nike huarache to the bowl, said: pandora rings "is indeed my mother to do the soup, omega watches is delicious! At this north face backpacks point, swarovski crystal my new balance tears could rolex replica not help dripping in the soup, I quickly concealed barbour women jackets to: "Gillian, soup splashed my north face jackets eyes, tears are spicy out, and help ray ban me coach outlet sale find some paper!" Yes, since coach outlet online college To now have womens hoodies not pandora jewellery been ray ban sunglasses home, do nfl seahawks not nets jersey know their minds are burberry thinking long champ about what is missing, and ray ban ultimately nothing, even the most swarovski basic marc jacobs handbags home are reebok forgotten, even the favorite watches taste gafas oakley of nike free shoes childhood true religion jeans outlet forgot, all of oakley sunglasses a sudden, christian louboutin Feeling roche run to be depressed, so hilfiger outlet heavy. hermes outlet An Yi ralph lauren tracksuits Jiao, I adidas sneakers grew up together nfl lions grew up small, almost always a bowl to eat, coach outlet two michael kors handbags people must eat michael kors outlet together at supra footwear the mcm bags same time, not her home nfl chiefs is my home. She also likes mia jersey to eat my mother the north face to do the bone soup, hours also bos jersey quarrel for cheap jerseys a bowl michael kors purses of soup, my mother vans schuhe always leaning to her, leaving ralph lauren outlet a soup zapatillas nike will cheap jerseys always be her, coach factory outlet online so she has vibram shoes been particularly nfl bills good nike.se relationship lunette ray ban pas cher with my mother, my mother to cheap eyeglasses be She is tory burch shoes like her oakley sunglasses own converse chucks daughter, ray ban wayfarer I am better, adidas shoes she babyliss is also my mother to the mother-like, the New Year ralph lauren holiday replica watches to her mother to buy things are double, new balance store a sure is to my polo ralph lauren mother. In my mother polo ralph lauren outlet my michael kors outlet online sale eyes is hermes birkin my son, that is not intimate, said nike mercurial vapor her daughter is a calvin klein small cotton jacket, but nike store I the north face was the exception. Now nike air max think about her will do celine black friday my mother's soup, it is nfl jaguars not cheap jerseys so surprised, air max 90 but inside the things that let puma outlet store me feel so, ashamed, I have hugo boss outlet to laugh at myself. From small to large, I beats audio regard her as a nfl dolphins sister, oakley in michael kors v?skor her eyes I ralph lauren polo am a naive, need to coach black friday take care toms.com of the louboutins sister, northface I am not afraid baseball jerseys of their parents, toms outlet but I am afraid of her parents let me do a housework, I will do oakley outlet something , But replica watches she did not, jordan release dates because air max 95 she said michael kors things, so kate spade I michael kors would burberry handbags like to talk back nfl eagles to the top, so I philipp plein clothes can not find a reason. woolrich outlet online So ecco women shoes once the words michael kors or adidas something to me to discuss, I ralph lauren outlet am 100% obedient, and ralph lauren shirts also very happy. Because sometimes she cheap michael kors and her parents new balance shoes spoiled me, there are hollister clothing store things, michael kors purses she will hollister carry for me, levis outlet store including in front coach outlet of my parents, I have burberry handbags been such pandora a softball bats person, a soccer outlet online personal and proud of pride, so beats by dre in front of nike air max me almost Transparent, burberry outlet online without coach outlet any tory burch sale thoughts and secrets, shoes on sale there is swarovski nothing unhappy converse she nike roshe will teach me. Carrying this familiar, hermes bags remnants lacoste polos of ray ban outlet thick culture has been the nfl rams bone soup, oakley my heart Bai jerseys from china Si Quan, heavy mont blanc pens memories burberry outlet and weight, eat two, some go marc jacobs outlet God, "Luoxi, how washington wizards the? cheap true religion Or do not want toronto raptors to eat? You are genetically injured bone, and air jordan retro will drink more soup, good, obedient! shop coach factory ", barbour women jackets I energetically grab rolex a few mouthfuls, drink soup. Heart michael kors outlet online can not tell converse outlet the ashamed and moved, swarovski there michael kors is cheap michael kors a trace michael kors of inexplicable heartache, in the meditation versace shoes outlet moment turned and found that the nba jerseys table nike air max 2015 is now a few more flower vase, is the rose and hibiscus flowers. "Luoxi, you need to nfl bears do not nike online love true religion jeans women your pandora bracelets ruthless man to get their own so embarrassed so unbearable? With me all worried about you, for rayban your distressed!" I did nike mercurial not tell coach factory online her how nfl redskins I was injured, she was longchamp black friday Such louboutin as ralph lauren online the coach factory outlet online old nike outlet to understand me, "usually to know how mcm backpack outlet to take care of themselves, I also do not have the north face outlet a few days to barbour outlet see you, find you thomas sabo uk play, you valentino shoes outlet are so, how nike outlet store do you promise me uhren to forget? cleveland cavaliers jerseys Well, do not hurt anything nba jerseys Own, that is www.tommyhilfiger.nl not worth it! cheap oakley sunglasses "In her nervous tone of longchamp outlet worry, I really think free run I'm sorry for her, nfl azcardinals really coach handbags outlet worried that michael kors outlet my timberland outlet mother prada sunglasses will thomas sabo not know it!

michael kors outlet online sale

chanyuan

2017.04.25 13:07:00

chanyuan2017.04.25

links of london

cartier watches for sale

swarovski outlet

polo outlet

thomas sabo charms

louis vuitton

polo outlet

michael kors outlet

ray ban sunglasses uk

pandora jewelry

louis vuitton outlet stores

cheap oakley sunglasses

louis vuitton outlet online

oakley sunglasses

michael kors handbags

polo ralph lauren outlet

christian louboutin shoes

yeezy boost 350

michael kors handbags

ray ban sunglasses

beats by dr dre

longchamp handbags

marc jacobs outlet

longchamp outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

puma outlet

rolex watches

louis vuitton outlet

michael kors handbags

michael kors canada

cheap ray ban sunglasses

mont blanc pens

cheap jordans

ralph lauren

coach outlet online

cheap oakley sunglasses

oakley sunglasses

coach factory outlet

polo outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

air max 90

polo ralph lauren outlet

michael kors outlet online

nike trainers

cheap ray bans

longchamp outlet

ray ban sunglasses

oakley sunglasses wholesale

adidas wings

louis vuitton handbags

cartier watches for women

cheap oakley sunglasses

air max 90

chrome hearts outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

michael kors wallets for women

cartier outlet

nike trainers

louis vuitton outlet stores

louis vuitton outlet

vans shoes

oakley sunglasses

nike store

michael kors uk

ralph lauren outlet

oakley sunglasses sale

polo outlet

burberry outlet

gucci outlet online

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

beats by dre

cheap nba jerseys

nike air max

true religion jeans

fitflops sale clearance

michael kors outlet online

michael kors handbags

oakley sunglasses wholesale

polo outlet

coach outlet online

lebron james shoes

michael kors outlet clearance

louis vuitton handbags

pandora jewelry

louis vuitton outlet

michael kors factory outlet

fitflops

michael kors outlet

coach outlet online

longchamp

mulberry sale

louis vuitton outlet clearance

nike foamposite

cheap oakley sunglasses

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

burberry outlet

fitflops

Basketball Shoes

louis vuitton outlet

michael kors handbags

coach outlet clearance

cheap oakley sunglasses

cheap nfl jerseys

michael kors outlet online

coach outlet online

cheap mlb jerseys

burberry outlet

sac louis vuitton pas cher

mulberry handbags

herve leger outlet

coach factory outlet

cazal sunglasses

michael kors outlet clearance

cheap jordans

louis vuitton outlet

louis vuitton outlet

ray ban sunglasses

air max 90

coach factory outlet

adidas nmd

nike shoes

cheap ray ban sunglasses

fitflops

michael kors outlet

coach outlet

true religion jeans

coach outlet

rolex uk

michael kors handbags outlet

iphone case

polo shirts

cartier outlet

soccer jerseys

polo ralph lauren

swarovski jewellery

oakley sunglasses

ralph lauren polo

nfl jerseys wholesale

ralph lauren

hollister

tory burch outlet

oakley sunglasses

borse gucci

louis vuitton outlet

coach outlet

swarovski crystal

true religion jeans

louis vuitton outlet online

cheap oakley sunglasses

cheap ray ban sunglasses

ralph lauren polo

true religion jeans

yeezy boost

coach outlet

swarovski crystal

adidas shoes

hermes belts

mulberry handbags

ray-ban sunglasses

ray ban sunglasses

louis vuitton

louis vuitton

cheap jordans

borse louis vuitton

ralph lauren outlet

polo pas cher

chrome hearts

swarovski jewelry

coach outlet store online

michael kors handbags clearance

oakley sunglasses wholesale

ferragamo shoes

christian louboutin shoes

polo ralph lauren

michael kors handbags outlet

gucci outlet

hollister clothing

louis vuitton outlet stores

christian louboutin outlet

nike trainers

longchamp outlet

football shirts

cheap oakley sunglasses

oakley sunglasses wholesale

oakley sunglasses wholesale

cheap oakley sunglasses

fitflops shoes

polo ralph lauren

coach outlet

mulberry bags

gucci outlet

hollister clothing

christian louboutin outlet

polo outlet store

Nike Free shoes

kobe shoes

nike shoes

ysl outlet

true religion jeans

michael kors outlet clearance

oakley sunglasses

polo outlet online

lebron james shoes

reebok outlet store

air max 90

adidas nmd runner

michael kors handbags

valentino outlet

oakley sunglasses

hollister sale

nike store uk

polo ralph lauren outlet

louis vuitton

cheap oakley sunglasses

coach factory outlet

yeezy boost 350

instyler ionic styler

coach outlet online

rolex outlet

ray ban sunglasses wholesale

christian louboutin shoes

burberry outlet

polo ralph lauren

michael kors outlet clearance

louis vuitton outlet online

louis vuitton outlet

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

ray ban sunglasses

true religion jeans

louis vuitton

oakley sunglasses wholesale

true religion jeans

tory burch outlet online

basketball shoes

oakley sunglasses sale

swarovski crystal

gucci outlet online

chrome hearts

gucci borse

mulberry bags

roshe run

christian louboutin online

asics

mulberry handbags sale

nike shoes uk

tory burch outlet

juicy couture outlet

michael kors outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

true religion jeans

louis vuitton handbags

cheap ray ban sunglasses

ray ban sunglasses

air max uk

christian louboutin sale

coach outlet

lacoste pas cher

cheap oakley sunglasses

polo ralph lauren

ferragamo outlet

gucci handbags

nike shoes for women

tory burch outlet online

oakley sunglasses

swarovski outlet

louis vuitton

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

nike huarache

louis vuitton

thomas sabo

nike air max 2015

nike store uk

adidas uk

ferragamo shoes

coach outlet online

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

kobe bryant shoes

louis vuitton handbags

christian louboutin outlet

christian louboutin outlet

christian louboutin

ralph lauren

chrome hearts outlet

replica watches

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

ray ban sunglasses

ray ban wayfarer

fitflops sale clearance

oakley sunglasses

nike roshe run

polo shirts

louis vuitton outlet

coach outlet store online

polo ralph lauren

dior sunglasses

tory burch outlet online

mcm outlet

oakley sunglasses sale

coach outlet

mizuno running shoes

coach outlet online

michael kors outlet clearance

louis vuitton outlet stores

ralph lauren outlet

true religion outlet

michael kors outlet

ralph lauren outlet

michael kors

reebok trainers

michael kors outlet clearance

cheap nike shoes

polo outlet

louis vuitton

nba jerseys

rolex watches,rolex watches,swiss watches,watches for men,watches for women,omega watches,replica watches,rolex watches for sale,rolex replica,rolex watch,cartier watches,rolex submariner,fake rolex,rolex replica watches,replica rolex

christian louboutin

jordan shoes

michael kors outlet online

coach outlet

gucci bags

los angeles lakers

jerseys wholesale

polo ralph lauren

ferragamo shoes

lacoste polo shirts

coach outlet clearance

longchamp handbags

cheap ray ban sunglasses

gucci outlet online

fitflops sale clearance

nike roshe run

rolex watches

nike air force 1

nba jerseys wholesale

cheap snapbacks

ferragamo outlet

coach factory outlet

oakley sunglasses

louis vuitton

hermes outlet

ed hardy clothing

longchamp

hollister uk

coach outlet

hollister clothing

nike outlet store

louis vuitton outlet

tory burch outlet

ray ban sunglasses

cheap ray bans

christian louboutin sale

oakley sunglasses

fitflops sale clearance

true religion uk

hollister clothing

air max 90

cheap jordan shoes

coach outlet

ralph lauren uk

coach factory outlet

cartier watches

adidas outlet store

polo outlet

ralph lauren outlet stores

soccer jerseys

cheap oakley sunglasses

gucci site ufficiale

cheap jordans

oakley sunglasses wholesale

cheap nfl jerseys

giuseppe zanotti outlet

pandora jewelry

hollister clothing

michael kors handbags

coach factory outlet

michael kors outlet online

louis vuitton

coach factory outlet online

michael kors outlet

coach outlet

ralph lauren outlet

ferragamo shoes

louis vuitton handbags

michael kors uk

cheap football shirts

gucci outlet

ray ban sunglasses

louis vuitton outlet stores

cheap oakley sunglasses

kate spade handbags

louis vuitton borse

cartier watches

nike air max

coach outlet store online

longchamp handbags

hermes bags

michael kors

louis vuitton uk

adidas nmd runner

oakley sunglasses

nike roshe

coach outlet store online

ralph lauren polo

tory burch outlet online store

louis vuitton outlet

coach outlet online

oakley sunglasses wholesale

rolex outlet

ray bans

oakley sunglasses

true religion jeans

beats headphones

coach outlet online

ray-ban sunglasses

cheap jordans

michael kors

fitflops sale

christian louboutin outlet

ray ban sunglasses uk

nike air max

michael kors outlet

ray-ban sunglasses

gucci handbags

omega watches

cheap ray ban sunglasses

los angeles lakers jerseys

beats by dr dre

coach outlet online

polo ralph lauren

pandora outlet

louis vuitton handbags

fitflops

michael kors handbags

futbol baratas

ray ban sunglasses

hollister shirts

michael kors handbags

burberry canada

oakley sunglasses

michael kors outlet clearance

oakley sunglasses

coach outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

ralph lauren uk

coach outlet online

replica watches

polo ralph lauren

adidas trainers

fitflops

ecco outlet

coach factory outlet

kate spade handbags

hermes birkin

yeezy boost

tory burch outlet stores

louis vuitton outlet

christian louboutin

fitflops shoes

bottega veneta outlet

coach outlet clearance

coach outlet online

cheap ray bans

air max uk

mcm backpack

swarovski outlet

rolex watches

coach factory outlet

mulberry handbags

oakley sunglasses wholesale

fitflops sale clearance

prada handbags

fitflops sale clearance

michael kors outlet

mbt shoes

nike mercurial

michael kors handbags

swarovski jewelry

ray ban sunglasses

pandora charms sale clearance

louis vuitton uk

michael kors handbags clearance

hollister clothing

pandora jewellery

true religion sale

cheap nfl jerseys

nike blazer pas cher

jordan shoes

michael kors outlet

ray ban sunglasses

cheap ray ban sunglasses

oakley sunglasses sale

rolex watches for sale

new balance shoes

louis vuitton pas cher

prada shoes

louis vuitton

oakley sunglasses wholesale

nike shoes

nike free 5

ralph lauren polo

gucci outlet

coach outlet online

pandora outlet

ralph lauren

swarovski crystal

coach outlet

michael kors handbags sale

ray ban sunglasses

ray ban sunglasses

polo ralph lauren

oakley sunglasses wholesale

cheap jordans for sale

coach outlet online coach factory outlet

mulberry outlet

polo outlet

ray ban sunglasses outlet

ray bans

polo ralph lauren

ferragamo outlet

tods outlet

michael kors handbags

mulberry handbags

tory burch outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

christian louboutin uk

ray ban sunglasses

louis vuitton

nike outlet

nike outlet store

kd shoes

louis vuitton outlet store

kevin durant shoes

nike roshe one

louis vuitton

rolex watches

coach outlet online

coach factory outlet

louis vuitton outlet

louis vuitton outlet

true religion outlet

mulberry handbags

michael kors factory outlet

christian louboutin outlet

prada sunglasses

adidas shoes

cleveland cavaliers jersey

oakley sunglasses

coach outlet online

coach factory outlet

cheap ray ban sunglasses

michael kors bags

coach outlet online

cheap ray ban sunglasses

converse shoes

fred perry polo shirts

louis vuitton

louis vuitton

michael kors outlet online

kate spade

michael kors

michael kors handbags

cheap mlb jerseys

polo outlet

cheap ray bans

coach outlet online

christian louboutin shoes

montblanc pens

swarovski crystal

kate spade outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet

louis vuitton outlet

michael kors handbags outlet

nike trainers

coach outlet

louis vuitton outlet

polo outlet stores

michael kors outlet clearance

cheap oakley sunglasses

coach outlet online

michael kors outlet online

christian louboutin

ray ban sunglasses

cheap jordans free shipping

oakley sunglasses wholesale

true religion uk

michael kors outlet

true religion jeans

mac cosmetics sale

ralph lauren shirts

coach factory outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

ralph lauren uk

nike blazer pas cher

polo ralph lauren

ray bans

michael kors

michael kors outlet

cheap nba jerseys

louis vuitton

nike shoes

ralph lauren pas cher

oakley sunglasses

ralph lauren

cartier watches

fitflops sale clearance

coach outlet

coach factory outlet

louis vuitton outlet

coach handbags

prada outlet

michael kors factory outlet

cheap nhl jerseys

supra shoes

ralph lauren polo shirts

michael kors outlet clearance

michael kors outlet

oakley sunglasses

michael kors outlet

coach outlet

rolex watches

ecco shoes

christian louboutin outlet

true religion outlet

oakley sunglasses

kobe 9

louis vuitton online

michael kors handbags

hermes belt

ray ban sunglasses

pandora outlet

jordan shoes

rolex watches

ralph lauren outlet

michael kors wallets

ralph lauren polo

mac cosmetics

air jordan 4

polo ralph lauren

cheap jerseys wholesale

longchamp handbags

michael kors outlet clearance

cheap oakley sunglasses

salomon shoes

louis vuitton outlet

gucci outlet

oakley sunglasses

tory burch shoes

michael kors outlet clearance

salomon outlet

michael kors outlet stores

pandora charms

nike huarache

cartier watches

louis vuitton

louis vuitton outlet

michael kors outlet

louis vuitton outlet clearance

swarovski uk

michael kors outlet store

louis vuitton outlet

oakley sunglasses

oakley sunglasses

coach factory outlet

ralph lauren polo

swarovski crystal

polo ralph lauren

louis vuitton handbags

rolex watches

cleveland cavaliers jerseys

ray ban sunglasses

longchamp handbags

polo outlet stores

fitflops outlet

coach outlet canada

louis vuitton outlet online

true religion jeans

coach outlet

tory burch outlet

hzx

2017.04.25 14:44:22

nike roshe run

cheap ray ban sunglasses

ralph lauren polo

valentino shoes

pandora outlet

oakley outlet

converse shoes

nike cortez classic

longchamp outlet

tory burch outlet

pandora charms

adidas originals superstar

coach outlet

true religion outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

clarks sandals

coach outlet store online

coach factory outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

adidas ultra boost shoes

adidas predator

coach outlet

pandora jewelry

snapback hats

mbt outlets

vibram fivefingers seeya

cheap oakley sunglasses

coach outlet store online

prada outlet

nike mercurial superfly

gucci outlet

christian louboutin sneakers

nike jordan shoes

red bottom heels

adidas outlet store

oakley sunglasses outlet

the north face outlet

michael kors handbags

longchamp handbags

ralph lauren polo

mcm handbags

michael kors handbags

cheap jordans

oakley vault

michael kors purses

michael kors outlet

mlb jerseys custom

fitflops sale

north face

adidas outlet

polo outlet

kd shoes

pandora charms sale clearance

vans for sale

coach outlet

nike air max uk

michael kors outlet

coach purses

michael kors outlet

michael kors handbags

michael kors outlet

supra outlet

nfl jerseys

cheap nfl jerseys

pandora charms

cheap ray bans

fitflops shoes

michael kors outlet online sale

cheap jordan shoes

ray ban clubmaster

cheap ray ban sunglasses

air force 1 shoes

adidas nitrocharge

michael kors handbags

oakley sunglasses outlet

columbia shoes men

cheap oakley sunglasses

salvatore ferragamo shoes

oakley vault

burberry scarf

ysl outlet

michael kors outlet online

longchamp pas cher

louis vuitton

christian louboutin sale

reebok outlet

louboutin outlet

christian louboutin sale

ysl bags

thibaut courtois jersey

christian louboutin shoes

adidas trainers uk

birkenstock sale

clarks outlet

lebron shoes

michael kors outlet online

vans store

mcm handbags

michael kors outlet online

fitflops sandals

hzx20170425
문서 첨부 제한 : 0Byte/ 2.00MB
파일 제한 크기 : 2.00MB (허용 확장자 : *.*)
List of Articles
번호 제목 조회 수
공지 교회 내에서 행해지는 다단계 --- 한국장로신문 update [3] 66095
공지 교회는 장사하는 곳이 아니다. / 김정태(베뢰아대학원대학교 신약학 교수) update [5] 71835
공지 다단계 판매와 교회( 그리스도인의 직업으로 적합한가 외...) updatefile [5] 62883
» 성도여 흔들리지 맙시다 /베뢰아사람 / 한국신학 update [4] 53309
17 [살며 사랑하며-이근미] 바쁜 지금 봉사합시다 update [4] 54301
16 [교회와 이단] 373 - 다단계에서 인간관계 형성의 문제점 update [5] 54547
15 또 다른 기독교인이 바라본 다단계에 관한 글 update [3] 55564
14 다단계하는 하는 년들은 보아라 update [3] 55706
13 ‘다단계’가 교회 망친다 “재원확보·선교” 명목 급속히 확산 update [7] 56972
12 어떤 기독교인이 바라본 다단계에 관한 글 (암웨이등...) update [4] 57765
11 교회가 다단계 판매업자들 '영업장'인가? update [5] 60054
10 교회 안에서 다단계에 대해(암웨이) / 모교회홈피에서 update [3] 60626
9 다단계 판매에 대한 기독교 윤리적 비판 update [6] 61451
8 월 1,000 만원의 허황된 꿈 / 흩어지는 교회 update [5] 61504
7 권사님이 다단계 판매조직 교회에 확장해 피해 커 국민일보 / 2012. 06. 28 update [5] 61652
6 다단계에 신도 2만8000명 끌어들인 목사들 update [6] 61784
5 어떤 기독교인이 바라본 다단계 판매에 관한 글 --- 싸이월드 update [4] 62407
4 교회내 다단계 판매 어떻게 보십니까? update [4] 63481
3 다음에서 퍼온 기독교인이 본 다단계 update [5] 64395
2 다단계 판매업 종사자에 대하여 지도자들이 취해야 할 입장 / 예수그리스도 후기성도교회 (몰몬교 개인사이트에서) update [7] 64913
1 하느님과 돈, 그리고 다단계 판매 (CBS 방송 칼럼) update [6] 96270
X
Login

브라우저를 닫더라도 로그인이 계속 유지될 수 있습니다. 로그인 유지 기능을 사용할 경우 다음 접속부터는 로그인을 하실 필요가 없습니다. 단, 게임방, 학교 등 공공장소에서 이용 시 개인정보가 유출될 수 있으니 꼭 로그아웃을 해주세요.

X